Meta-analysis of the efficacy of camel milk consumption for improving autism symptoms in children in randomized clinical trials

被引:2
作者
Kandeel, Mahmoud [1 ,2 ]
Morsy, Mohamed A. [3 ,4 ]
Al Khodair, Khalid M. [5 ]
Alhojaily, Sameer [1 ]
机构
[1] King Faisal Univ, Coll Vet Med, Dept Biomed Sci, Al Hasa, Saudi Arabia
[2] Kafrelsheikh Univ, Fac Vet Med, Dept Pharmacol, Kafrelsheikh, Egypt
[3] King Faisal Univ, Coll Clin Pharm, Dept Pharmaceut Sci, Al Hasa, Saudi Arabia
[4] Minia Univ, Fac Med, Dept Pharmacol, El Minia, Egypt
[5] King Faisal Univ, Coll Vet Med, Dept Anat, Al Hasa, Saudi Arabia
关键词
Autism spectrum disorder; Camel milk; Meta-analysis; Therapeutic intervention; Childhood autism rating scale;
D O I
10.5455/OVJ.2024.v14.i9.33
中图分类号
S85 [动物医学(兽医学)];
学科分类号
0906 ;
摘要
Background: Camel milk has emerged as a potential complementary therapy for autism spectrum disorder (ASD). Aim: This study aimed to gather evidence from randomized controlled trials (RCTs) on the effectiveness of camel milk consumption in improving symptoms and associated measures in children with ASD. Methods: Comprehensive searches of multiple databases were conducted up to March 14, 2024, for RCTs that evaluated whether camel milk consumption by children with ASD was more beneficial than the consumption of a control substance. Quality and bias analyses and meta-anlaysis data were synthesized and analyzed. Results: Of 136 records identified, 5 RCTs (n n = 299 children) were selected. The mean difference in scores on the childhood autism rating scale (CARS) for the group given camel milk and the control groups was a mean deviation (MD) -0.75, 95% CI-1.97 to 0.47, p = 0.23. The mean difference in CARS scores in the subgroup analyses for raw camel milk was MD-0.95, 95% CI-2.33 to 0.44, p = 0.18 and boiled camel milk MD -0.50, 95% CI-1.93 to 0.93, p = 0.49. A qualitative synthesis found that raw camel milk intake led to improvements in various social behaviors in children with ASD. Camel milk consumption resulted in increased levels of anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, and immunomodulatory biomarkers, with some differences observed between patients given raw camel milk and boiled camel milk. Conclusion: Camel milk shows promise in improving social behaviors and certain biochemical markers in children with ASD, although the current meta-analysis did not document a significant statistical difference in CARS scores for the children studied. Future studies should focus on rigorous RCTs and larger sample sizes to substantiate these preliminary findings.
引用
收藏
页码:2441 / 2452
页数:12
相关论文
共 50 条
[41]   The composition of camel milk: A meta-analysis of the literature data [J].
Konuspayeva, G. ;
Faye, B. ;
Loiseau, G. .
JOURNAL OF FOOD COMPOSITION AND ANALYSIS, 2009, 22 (02) :95-101
[42]   Efficacy of vitamin D supplementation on depressive symptoms in older patients: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials [J].
Fu, Jiamin ;
Zhang, Yuchi ;
Chen, Xiaoyu ;
Yu, Xing ;
Yan, Maoxin ;
Jing, Biying ;
Yu, Hongjuan ;
Li, Wenzhen ;
Guo, Qi .
FRONTIERS IN MEDICINE, 2024, 11
[43]   Efficacy of health education on treatment of children with atopic dermatitis: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials [J].
Yunling Li ;
Ting Han ;
Wei Li ;
Yin Li ;
Xiaoxuan Guo ;
Lei Zheng .
Archives of Dermatological Research, 2020, 312 :685-695
[44]   Efficacy of health education on treatment of children with atopic dermatitis: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials [J].
Li, Yunling ;
Han, Ting ;
Li, Wei ;
Li, Yin ;
Guo, Xiaoxuan ;
Zheng, Lei .
ARCHIVES OF DERMATOLOGICAL RESEARCH, 2020, 312 (10) :685-695
[45]   Impact of soy milk consumption on cardiometabolic risk factors: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials [J].
Sohouli, Mohammad Hassan ;
Lari, Abolfazl ;
Fatahi, Somaye ;
Shidfar, Farzad ;
Gaman, Mihnea-Alexandru ;
Guimaraes, Nathalia Sernizon ;
Sindi, Ghufran Abdullatif ;
Mandili, Rasha Abdulaziz ;
Alzahrani, Ghaida Rashed ;
Abdulwahab, Rahaf Abdulrashid ;
Almuflihi, Alhanouf Mohammed ;
Alsobyani, Faris Mohammed ;
Mahmud, Amna Malik Albu ;
Nazzal, Osama ;
Alshaibani, Lama ;
Elmokid, Shouq ;
Abu-Zaid, Ahmed .
JOURNAL OF FUNCTIONAL FOODS, 2021, 83
[46]   Meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials on the efficacy of daikenchuto on improving intestinal dysfunction after abdominal surgery [J].
Zhang, Lei ;
Cheng, Yusheng ;
Li, Huizi ;
Zhou, Yufeng ;
Sun, Bo ;
Xu, Leibo .
ANNALS OF SURGICAL TREATMENT AND RESEARCH, 2018, 95 (01) :7-15
[47]   Effect of coffee consumption on dyslipidemia: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials [J].
Du, Yanbin ;
Lv, Yuan ;
Zha, Wenting ;
Hong, Xiuqin ;
Luo, Qinghong .
NUTRITION METABOLISM AND CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASES, 2020, 30 (12) :2159-2170
[48]   Facial emotion training as an intervention in autism spectrum disorder: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials [J].
Zhang, Qianqian ;
Wu, Renjing ;
Zhu, Siyu ;
Le, Jiao ;
Chen, Yuanshu ;
Lan, Chunmei ;
Yao, Shuxia ;
Zhao, Weihua ;
Kendrick, Keith M. .
AUTISM RESEARCH, 2021, 14 (10) :2169-2182
[49]   Lifestyle medicine for anxiety symptoms: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials [J].
Wong, Vincent Wing-Hei ;
Ho, Fiona Yan-Yee ;
Shi, Nga-Kwan ;
Sarris, Jerome ;
Ng, Chee H. ;
Tam, Ophelia Kwan-Yee .
JOURNAL OF AFFECTIVE DISORDERS, 2022, 310 :354-368
[50]   Treatment Efficacy Differences of Sorafenib for Advanced Hepatocellular Carcinoma: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Clinical Trials [J].
Shao, Yu-Yun ;
Shau, Wen-Yi ;
Chan, Soa-Yu ;
Lu, Li-Chun ;
Hsu, Chih-Hung ;
Cheng, Ann-Lii .
ONCOLOGY, 2015, 88 (06) :345-352