Background Malnutrition is a potentially preventable risk factor for surgery. This systematic review examines nutritional management strategies aiming to enhance surgical outcomes. Methods A systematic search was conducted in PubMed for English-language studies published between July 1, 2004, and July 1, 2024, involving adult surgical patients. Study selection focused on four key themes: (1) nutritional screening and assessment, (2) preoperative nutritional therapy, (3) nutritional support in critically ill surgical patients, and (4) postoperative nutritional rehabilitation. Studies in non-surgical cohorts, letters, and case reports were excluded. Reference lists of relevant studies were manually screened for additional sources. Results Of 2763 studies identified, 251 met the inclusion criteria and 85 were added after manual screening, contributing to a total of 341 papers for the review. The prevalence of malnutrition varied widely by procedure, with the highest rates observed in pancreatic and esophagogastric operations. Preoperative malnutrition was strongly associated with increased postoperative complications, infections, prolonged hospital stay, and higher mortality. The Malnutrition Universal Screening Tool (MUST) was effective in identifying at-risk patients. Preoperative nutritional interventions, including dietitian-led counseling, oral supplementation, and enteral or parenteral nutrition, may reduce complications and improve outcomes. Critically ill patients benefited from structured enteral and parenteral strategies. Early postoperative nutrition within enhanced recovery after surgery (ERAS) protocols are linked to less complications and shorter hospital stay. Conclusion Malnutrition significantly impacts surgical outcomes, necessitating early identification and intervention. Standardized management is key to improving recovery and reducing complications. Future research should focus on refining diagnostic tools, assessing nutritional requirements, optimizing perioperative nutritional strategies, and establishing long-term nutritional follow-up guidelines for surgical patients.