Associations Between Body Mass Index, Gait Biomechanics, and In Vivo Cartilage Function After Exercise in Those With Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction

Background: Both high body mass index (BMI) and anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) independently influence knee osteoarthritis risk. Preliminary evidence shows the combination of these risk factors leads to poorer recovery and altered biomechanical outcomes after ACLR, but few studies have directly evaluated early changes in cartilage health between normal-BMI and high-BMI groups in this population. Purpose: To evaluate ultrasound-based measures of cartilage strain and compositional changes (via echo-intensity [EI]) in response to an incline walking stress test between normal-BMI and high-BMI individuals with ACLR. A secondary evaluation was conducted of associations between habitual walking biomechanics (ie, ground-reaction forces, sagittal knee kinetics and kinematics) and cartilage strain and EI outcomes. Study Design: Controlled laboratory study. Methods: Gait biomechanics and femoral trochlear ultrasound analyses were evaluated in 64 participants with ACLR who had normal BMI (BMI < 27.0; n = 40) and high BMI (BMI >= 27.0; n = 24). Ultrasound images were collected bilaterally before and after an incline treadmill walk, and medial and lateral trochlear strain and EI changes pre-post exercise were used to compare BMI groups and limbs. Gait outcomes included ground-reaction forces, peak sagittal plane knee moments, angles, and excursions and were used to determine associations with cartilage outcomes in the entire cohort. Results: High-BMI individuals with ACLR exhibited greater medial trochlear cartilage strain in the ACLR limb compared with normal-BMI individuals (approximately 6%; P < .01). In those with high BMI, the ACLR limb exhibited greater medial trochlear strain relative to non-ACLR limbs (approximately 4%; P < .05), but between-limb differences were not observed in the normal-BMI group (P > .05). Medial trochlear EI changes were greater bilaterally in those with high BMI compared with normal-BMI ACLR counterparts (approximately 10%; P < .01). Last, individuals who walked with greater peak knee flexion angles exhibited less medial cartilage strain (Delta R-2 = 0.06; P = .025). Conclusion: The data suggested that high BMI affects cartilage functional properties after ACLR, whereas smaller knee flexion angles were associated with larger medial cartilage strain. Clinical Relevance: High-BMI individuals with ACLR may represent a subset of patients exhibiting earlier declines in cartilage functional integrity in response to loading, necessitating additional or more targeted interventions to mitigate disease development.