The Challenges of Comparative Criminology Research

被引:0
作者
Zhang, Jie [1 ]
Yu, Pin [1 ]
Liu, Jianhong [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Macau, Fac Law, Ave Univ, Taipa, Macao, Peoples R China
关键词
Comparative criminology; Western-centrism; Quantitative research; Cross-national surveys; Cross-cultural studies; CROSS-NATIONAL RESEARCH; ASIAN CRIMINOLOGY; CRIMINAL-JUSTICE; AMERICAN-SOCIETY; CRIME; CULTURE; PARADIGM; SOUTHERN; WORLD; PERCEPTIONS;
D O I
10.1007/s11417-025-09452-6
中图分类号
DF [法律]; D9 [法律];
学科分类号
0301 ;
摘要
There is a growing recognition of the significance of comparative research in criminology. However, this field faces several persistent challenges that hinder its development. These challenges may limit the validity of comparative research findings and introduce potential biases. If not addressed appropriately, these challenges can impede the growth of comparative criminology and its contributions. These primary challenges include a predominance of Western-centric perspectives, the ambiguity arising from involving culture as an explanatory factor in quantitative studies, difficulties in conducting survey research across different countries, and inadequacies in the comparative units utilized. This paper seeks to comprehensively review these challenges in detail and explore the path for the advancement of future research in comparative criminology.
引用
收藏
页码:83 / 97
页数:15
相关论文
共 50 条
[41]   Asian Criminology's Expansion and Advancement of Research and Crime Control Practices [J].
Belknap, Joanne .
ASIAN JOURNAL OF CRIMINOLOGY, 2016, 11 (04) :249-264
[42]   A green branch of criminology? Thoughts on green criminology [J].
Schmidt, Holger .
KRIMINOLOGISCHES JOURNAL, 2013, 45 (04) :260-278
[43]   Theoretical Criminology in the Journal of Criminal Investigation and Criminology [J].
Jager, Matjaz .
REVIJA ZA KRIMINALISTIKO IN KRIMINOLOGIJO, 2019, 70 (02) :63-72
[44]   Deconstructing Criminology's Origin Stories [J].
Carrington, Kerry ;
Hogg, Russell .
ASIAN JOURNAL OF CRIMINOLOGY, 2017, 12 (03) :181-197
[45]   Criminology, crime and criminal justice in Croatia [J].
Kalac, Anna-Maria Getos ;
Bezic, Reana .
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF CRIMINOLOGY, 2017, 14 (02) :242-266
[46]   Translational Criminology: Toward Best Practice [J].
Pesta, George B. ;
Blomberg, Thomas G. ;
Ramos, Javier ;
Ranson, J. W. Andrew .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE, 2019, 44 (03) :499-518
[47]   Contextuality, Commensurability, and Comparability in Comparative Research: Learning From Chinese Relationship Research [J].
Wang, Georgette ;
Huang, Yi-Hui Christine .
CROSS-CULTURAL RESEARCH, 2016, 50 (02) :154-177
[48]   Environmental crime and green criminology in South Eastern Europe-practice and research [J].
Eman, Katja ;
Mesko, Gorazd ;
Dobovsek, Bojan ;
Sotlar, Andrej .
CRIME LAW AND SOCIAL CHANGE, 2013, 59 (03) :341-358
[49]   Advancing interdisciplinary research on illegal wildlife trade using a conservation criminology framework [J].
Boratto, Rachel ;
Gibbs, Carole .
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF CRIMINOLOGY, 2021, 18 (06) :777-798
[50]   Photo-Elicitation Technique: Utility and Challenges in Clinical Research [J].
Kyololo, O'Brien M. ;
Stevens, Bonnie J. ;
Songok, Julia .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF QUALITATIVE METHODS, 2023, 22