Constraining the Thickness of the Conductive Portion of Europa's Ice Shell Using Sparse Radar Echoes

被引:1
作者
Schroeder, Dustin M. [1 ,2 ]
Wolfenbarger, Natalie S. [1 ]
Steinbruegge, Gregor B. [3 ]
Culberg, Riley [4 ]
Howell, Samuel M. [3 ]
Spiers, Elizabeth [5 ]
Styczinski, Marshall [6 ]
机构
[1] Stanford Univ, Dept Geophys, Stanford, CA 94305 USA
[2] Stanford Univ, Dept Elect Engn, Stanford, CA 94305 USA
[3] CALTECH, Jet Prop Lab, Pasadena, CA USA
[4] Cornell Univ, Dept Earth & Atmospher Sci, Ithaca, NY USA
[5] Univ Texas Austin, Inst Geophys, Austin, TX USA
[6] Blue Marble Space Inst Sci, Seattle, WA USA
基金
美国国家航空航天局;
关键词
SUBSURFACE WATER; ATTENUATION; PROSPECTS; SOUNDER; MODELS; OCEAN;
D O I
10.1029/2024GL110635
中图分类号
P [天文学、地球科学];
学科分类号
07 ;
摘要
Ice penetrating radar sounding is the primary geophysical technique for imaging the subsurface of planetary ice shells and has the potential to directly detect the ice-ocean interface. However, many sounding measurements may lack laterally extensive features that would aid their physical interpretation. In this scenario, the detection of sparse echoes can also provide rich information on ice shell properties. To explore and demonstrate this possibility, we consider three cases of isolated radar signatures: pore-curing, eutectic melt, and unattributed echoes. We show that through detection of unattributed sparse echoes, the thickness of the conductive portion of Europa's ice shell can be constrained. These constraints can be improved by attributing sparse echoes to thermally diagnostic signatures such as pore-curing and eutectic melt. Notably, this approach to radar sounding echo analysis is particularly compatible with joint inversions with other planetary geophysical observations such as tidal deformation, magnetic induction, and rotation state. Upcoming missions to explore Europa, the icy moon of Jupiter, include ice penetrating radar sounders as part of their instrument payloads. One of the primary goals of these instruments is to investigate the subsurface structure and thickness of Europa's ice shell. It's possible that the radar profiles returned by these instruments will include imagery of the ice-ocean interface across much of the moon, providing a direct measurement of ice-shell thickness. However, we show that, even in the absence of such imagery, a small number of isolated radar echoes can be used to measure the thickness and structure of the ice shell. These echoes include scattering from porous ice near the moon's surface and pockets of melt water within the shell. Radar-detectable interfaces from the subsurface of Europa's ice shell can be thermally diagnostic The thickness of the conductive portion of Europa's ice shell can be constrained without direct detection of the ice-ocean interface The detection of sparse echoes places a lower bound on conductive ice shell thickness based on the two-way integrated radar attenuation
引用
收藏
页数:9
相关论文
共 37 条
[1]   Bright prospects for radar detection of Europa's ocean [J].
Aglyamov, Yury ;
Schroeder, Dustin M. ;
Vance, Steven D. .
ICARUS, 2017, 281 :334-337
[2]   Exploring the Composition of Europa with the Upcoming Europa Clipper Mission [J].
Becker, T. M. ;
Zolotov, M. Y. ;
Gudipati, M. S. ;
Soderblom, J. M. ;
McGrath, M. A. ;
Henderson, B. L. ;
Hedman, M. M. ;
Choukroun, M. ;
Clark, R. N. ;
Chivers, C. ;
Wolfenbarger, N. S. ;
Glein, C. R. ;
Castillo-Rogez, J. C. ;
Mousis, O. ;
Scanlan, K. M. ;
Diniega, S. ;
Seelos, F. P. ;
Goode, W. ;
Postberg, F. ;
Grima, C. ;
Hsu, H. -W. ;
Roth, L. ;
Trumbo, S. K. ;
Miller, K. E. ;
Chan, K. ;
Paranicas, C. ;
Brooks, S. M. ;
Soderlund, K. M. ;
McKinnon, W. B. ;
Hibbitts, C. A. ;
Smith, H. T. ;
Molyneux, P. M. ;
Gladstone, G. R. ;
Cable, M. L. ;
Ulibarri, Z. E. ;
Teolis, B. D. ;
Horanyi, M. ;
Jia, X. ;
Leonard, E. J. ;
Hand, K. P. ;
Vance, S. D. ;
Howell, S. M. ;
Quick, L. C. ;
Mishra, I. ;
Rymer, A. M. ;
Briois, C. ;
Blaney, D. L. ;
Raut, U. ;
Waite, J. H. ;
Retherford, K. D. .
SPACE SCIENCE REVIEWS, 2024, 220 (05)
[3]   The great thickness debate: Ice shell thickness models for Europa and comparisons with estimates based on flexure at ridges [J].
Billings, SE ;
Kattenhorn, SA .
ICARUS, 2005, 177 (02) :397-412
[4]   Radar for Europa Assessment and Sounding: Ocean to Near-Surface (REASON) [J].
Blankenship, Donald D. ;
Moussessian, Alina ;
Chapin, Elaine ;
Young, Duncan A. ;
Patterson, G. Wesley ;
Plaut, Jeffrey J. ;
Freedman, Adam P. ;
Schroeder, Dustin M. ;
Grima, Cyril ;
Steinbrugge, Gregor ;
Soderlund, Krista M. ;
Ray, Trina ;
Richter, Thomas G. ;
Jones-Wilson, Laura ;
Wolfenbarger, Natalie S. ;
Scanlan, Kirk M. ;
Gerekos, Christopher ;
Chan, Kristian ;
Seker, Ilgin ;
Haynes, Mark S. ;
Mlinar, Amy C. Barr ;
Bruzzone, Lorenzo ;
Campbell, Bruce A. ;
Carter, Lynn M. ;
Elachi, Charles ;
Gim, Yonggyu ;
Herique, Alain ;
Hussmann, Hauke ;
Kofman, Wlodek ;
Kurth, William S. ;
Mastrogiuseppe, Marco ;
Mckinnon, William B. ;
Moore, Jeffrey M. ;
Nimmo, Francis ;
Paty, Carol ;
Plettemeier, Dirk ;
Schmidt, Britney E. ;
Zolotov, Mikhail Y. ;
Schenk, Paul M. ;
Collins, Simon ;
Figueroa, Harry ;
Fischman, Mark ;
Tardiff, Eric ;
Berkun, Andy ;
Paller, Mimi ;
Hoffman, James P. ;
Kurum, Andy ;
Sadowy, Gregory A. ;
Wheeler, Kevin B. ;
Decrossas, Emmanuel .
SPACE SCIENCE REVIEWS, 2024, 220 (05)
[5]   An Interferometric Approach to Cross-Track Clutter Detection in Two-Channel VHF Radar Sounders [J].
Castelletti, Davide ;
Schroeder, Dustin M. ;
Hensley, Scott ;
Grima, Cyril ;
Ng, Gregory ;
Young, Duncan ;
Gim, Yonggyu ;
Bruzzone, Lorenzo ;
Moussessian, Alina ;
Blankenship, Don D. .
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON GEOSCIENCE AND REMOTE SENSING, 2017, 55 (11) :6128-6140
[6]   Radar detectability of a subsurface ocean on Europa [J].
Chyba, CF ;
Ostro, SJ ;
Edwards, BC .
ICARUS, 1998, 134 (02) :292-302
[7]   Double ridge formation over shallow water sills on Jupiter's moon Europa [J].
Culberg, Riley ;
Schroeder, Dustin M. ;
Steinbrugge, Gregor .
NATURE COMMUNICATIONS, 2022, 13 (01)
[8]   Firn Clutter Constraints on the Design and Performance of Orbital Radar Ice Sounders [J].
Culberg, Riley ;
Schroeder, Dustin M. .
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON GEOSCIENCE AND REMOTE SENSING, 2020, 58 (09) :6344-6361
[9]   Assessing the detectability of Europa's eutectic zone using radar sounding [J].
Culha, Cansu ;
Schroeder, Dustin M. ;
Jordan, Thomas M. ;
Haynes, Mark S. .
ICARUS, 2020, 339
[10]   Planned Geological Investigations of the Europa Clipper Mission [J].
Daubar, I. J. ;
Hayes, A. G. ;
Collins, G. C. ;
Craft, K. L. ;
Rathbun, J. A. ;
Spencer, J. R. ;
Wyrick, D. Y. ;
Bland, M. T. ;
Davies, A. G. ;
Ernst, C. M. ;
Howell, S. M. ;
Leonard, E. J. ;
McEwen, A. S. ;
Moore, J. M. ;
Phillips, C. B. ;
Prockter, L. M. ;
Quick, L. C. ;
Scully, J. E. C. ;
Soderblom, J. M. ;
Brooks, S. M. ;
Cable, M. ;
Cameron, M. E. ;
Chan, K. ;
Chivers, C. J. ;
Choukroun, M. ;
Cochrane, C. J. ;
Diniega, S. ;
Dombard, A. J. ;
Elder, C. M. ;
Gerekos, C. ;
Glein, C. ;
Greathouse, T. K. ;
Grima, C. ;
Gudipati, M. S. ;
Hand, K. P. ;
Hansen, C. ;
Hayne, P. ;
Hedman, M. ;
Hughson, K. ;
Jia, X. ;
Lawrence, J. ;
Meyer, H. M. ;
Miller, K. ;
Parekh, R. ;
Patterson, G. W. ;
Persaud, D. M. ;
Piqueux, S. ;
Retherford, K. D. ;
Scanlan, K. M. ;
Schenk, P. .
SPACE SCIENCE REVIEWS, 2024, 220 (01)