Experimental and numerical investigation of failure modes in RC frame structures designed using the equivalent linearization method

The codes of many countries currently employ the column-to-beam flexural strength ratio (CBFSR) based on frequent earthquake internal forces to achieve the expected strong-column-weak-beam (SCWB) ductile failure mode. However, real earthquake damage indicates a general failure to achieve SCWB. The design method based on frequent earthquake internal forces struggles to consider factors such as internal force redistribution and variable axial forces under rare earthquakes. Therefore, developing a seismic design method directly based on rare earthquake internal forces is crucial. The equivalent linearization method is a practical approach for obtaining the internal forces of RC frame structures under strong earthquakes without extensive nonlinear computations. In this paper, nonlinear finite element analyses of RC frame structures with expected SCWB failure modes under various structural parameters were conducted to obtain ductility coefficients under rare earthquakes. Using the equivalent linearization method based on secant stiffness, the equivalent stiffness and damping of beams and columns were calculated. Simplified parameters were determined for engineering applications to facilitate seismic design based on rare earthquake internal forces. Two RC frame structures were designed using both the equivalent linearization method and the CBFSR code method, and then subjected to pseudo-static lowcycle reciprocating loading tests. The study investigated failure modes and hysteretic energy dissipation, as well as overall stiffness and bearing capacity under earthquake conditions. Results showed that the equivalent linearization method can effectively direct RC frame structures to achieve the expected strong earthquake failure mode.The dynamic time history analysis was performed on finite element models of different heights, and the results indicated that the equivalent linearization method significantly reduced plastic hinge occurrences and ductility coefficients of column ends, resulting in improved seismic performance compared to the CBFSR code method.