共 46 条
Pore-scale deformation characteristics of hydrate-bearing sediments with gas replacement
被引:1
作者:

Huang, Lei
论文数: 0 引用数: 0
h-index: 0
机构:
Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China

Wu, Peng
论文数: 0 引用数: 0
h-index: 0
机构:
Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China

Wang, Yunhui
论文数: 0 引用数: 0
h-index: 0
机构:
Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China

Song, Yongchen
论文数: 0 引用数: 0
h-index: 0
机构:
Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China

Li, Yanghui
论文数: 0 引用数: 0
h-index: 0
机构:
Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China
机构:
[1] Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China
基金:
中国国家自然科学基金;
关键词:
Carbon sequestration;
Natural gas hydrate;
CO2;
replacement;
CT;
Microstructure;
Deformation characteristics;
CARBON-DIOXIDE;
METHANE;
SAND;
DISSOCIATION;
BEHAVIOR;
ARGON;
HEAT;
D O I:
10.1016/j.scitotenv.2024.176464
中图分类号:
X [环境科学、安全科学];
学科分类号:
08 ;
0830 ;
摘要:
Gas replacement method enables the simultaneous exploitation of natural gas and the realization of carbon capture, utilization, and storage (CCUS). Safe exploitation of hydrate-bearing sediments (HBS) has garnered significant attention, particularly concerning the engineering geological risks involved. Understanding deformation characteristics during shear after the replacement of HBS is crucial for safe and efficient exploitation. This study employs microfocus computer tomography and digital volume correlation (DVC) to investigate the deformation characteristics of HBS samples with varying replacement percentages. Key findings include: 1. An increase in failure strength of HBS is observed with higher replacement percentages due to improved hydrate cementation and consolidation under confining pressure. 2. DVC analysis shows that narrower radial displacement ranges are associated with increased pore compression, while wider ranges indicate greater particle repositioning. Frequent large axial displacements suggest significant pore compaction, whereas smaller axial displacements indicate particle movement and pore-filling phenomena. 3. The gas replacement process enhances the cementation structure of HBS without altering hydrate saturation, resulting in thinner shear bands and accelerated strain softening with higher replacement percentages. 4. The DVC approach effectively captures volumetric strain and deformation behaviors, offering valuable insights into sediment responses under shear. This study provides a theoretical reference for geological safety evaluation during gas replacement exploitation.
引用
收藏
页数:12
相关论文
共 46 条
- [21] Mechanical Characteristics of Underconsolidated Methane Hydrate- Bearing Clayed-Silty Sediments[J]. ENERGY & FUELS, 2023, 37 (09) : 6503 - 6514Liu, Weiguo论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat M, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat M, Dalian 116024, Peoples R ChinaChen, Pengyu论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat M, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat M, Dalian 116024, Peoples R ChinaWu, Peng论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat M, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat M, Dalian 116024, Peoples R ChinaYou, Zeshao论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat M, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat M, Dalian 116024, Peoples R ChinaWang, Lei论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Yanshan Univ, Sch Civil Engn & Mech, Qinhuangdao 066004, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat M, Dalian 116024, Peoples R ChinaHuang, Lei论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat M, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat M, Dalian 116024, Peoples R ChinaZhang, Shuheng论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat M, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat M, Dalian 116024, Peoples R ChinaYu, Tao论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat M, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat M, Dalian 116024, Peoples R ChinaLi, Yanghui论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat M, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat M, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China
- [22] Deformation behaviors of hydrate-bearing silty sediments during CH4-CO2 replacement[J]. JOURNAL OF PETROLEUM SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING, 2022, 211Luo, Tingting论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: China Univ Min & Technol, Sch Mech & Civil Engn, State Key Lab Geomech & Deep Underground Engn, Xuzhou 221116, Jiangsu, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China China Univ Min & Technol, Sch Mech & Civil Engn, State Key Lab Geomech & Deep Underground Engn, Xuzhou 221116, Jiangsu, Peoples R ChinaHan, Tao论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: China Univ Min & Technol, Sch Mech & Civil Engn, State Key Lab Geomech & Deep Underground Engn, Xuzhou 221116, Jiangsu, Peoples R China China Univ Min & Technol, Sch Mech & Civil Engn, State Key Lab Geomech & Deep Underground Engn, Xuzhou 221116, Jiangsu, Peoples R ChinaZhang, Tao论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: China Univ Min & Technol, Sch Mech & Civil Engn, State Key Lab Geomech & Deep Underground Engn, Xuzhou 221116, Jiangsu, Peoples R China China Univ Min & Technol, Sch Mech & Civil Engn, State Key Lab Geomech & Deep Underground Engn, Xuzhou 221116, Jiangsu, Peoples R ChinaLi, Yanghui论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China State Key Lab Nat Gas Hydrate, Beijing 100028, Peoples R China China Univ Min & Technol, Sch Mech & Civil Engn, State Key Lab Geomech & Deep Underground Engn, Xuzhou 221116, Jiangsu, Peoples R ChinaZhao, Xiaodong论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: China Univ Min & Technol, Sch Mech & Civil Engn, State Key Lab Geomech & Deep Underground Engn, Xuzhou 221116, Jiangsu, Peoples R China China Univ Min & Technol, Sch Mech & Civil Engn, State Key Lab Geomech & Deep Underground Engn, Xuzhou 221116, Jiangsu, Peoples R ChinaZhang, Chenyi论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: China Univ Min & Technol, Sch Mech & Civil Engn, State Key Lab Geomech & Deep Underground Engn, Xuzhou 221116, Jiangsu, Peoples R China China Univ Min & Technol, Sch Mech & Civil Engn, State Key Lab Geomech & Deep Underground Engn, Xuzhou 221116, Jiangsu, Peoples R ChinaSun, Xiang论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China China Univ Min & Technol, Sch Mech & Civil Engn, State Key Lab Geomech & Deep Underground Engn, Xuzhou 221116, Jiangsu, Peoples R ChinaSong, Yongchen论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China China Univ Min & Technol, Sch Mech & Civil Engn, State Key Lab Geomech & Deep Underground Engn, Xuzhou 221116, Jiangsu, Peoples R China
- [23] Comparative analysis of the consolidation and shear behaviors of CH4 and CO2 hydrate-bearing silty sediments[J]. JOURNAL OF NATURAL GAS SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING, 2020, 75Luo, Tingting论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R ChinaLi, Yanghui论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R ChinaMadhusudhan, B. N.论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Univ Southampton, Fac Engn & Environm, Southampton, Hants, England Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R ChinaZhao, Jiafei论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R ChinaSong, Yongchen论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China Dalian Univ Technol, Key Lab Ocean Energy Utilizat & Energy Conservat, Minist Educ, Dalian 116024, Peoples R China
- [24] Triaxial compressive properties of artificial methane-hydrate-bearing sediment[J]. JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SOLID EARTH, 2011, 116Miyazaki, Kuniyuki论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Natl Inst Adv Ind Sci & Technol, Methane Hydrate Res Ctr, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 3058569, Japan Natl Inst Adv Ind Sci & Technol, Methane Hydrate Res Ctr, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 3058569, JapanMasui, Akira论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Natl Inst Adv Ind Sci & Technol, Methane Hydrate Res Ctr, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 3058569, Japan Natl Inst Adv Ind Sci & Technol, Methane Hydrate Res Ctr, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 3058569, JapanSakamoto, Yasuhide论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Natl Inst Adv Ind Sci & Technol, Methane Hydrate Res Ctr, Inst Georesources & Environm, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 3058569, Japan Natl Inst Adv Ind Sci & Technol, Methane Hydrate Res Ctr, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 3058569, JapanAoki, Kazuo论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Natl Inst Adv Ind Sci & Technol, Methane Hydrate Res Ctr, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 3058569, Japan Natl Inst Adv Ind Sci & Technol, Methane Hydrate Res Ctr, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 3058569, JapanTenma, Norio论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Natl Inst Adv Ind Sci & Technol, Methane Hydrate Res Ctr, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 3058569, Japan Natl Inst Adv Ind Sci & Technol, Methane Hydrate Res Ctr, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 3058569, JapanYamaguchi, Tsutomu论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Toho Univ, Dept Environm Sci, Funabashi, Chiba 2748510, Japan Natl Inst Adv Ind Sci & Technol, Methane Hydrate Res Ctr, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 3058569, Japan
- [25] Dynamic in-situ imaging of methane hydrate formation and self-preservation in porous media[J]. MARINE AND PETROLEUM GEOLOGY, 2020, 115Nikitin, Viktor V.论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Lund Univ, Max Lab 4, 2 Fotongatan, S-22484 Lund, Sweden Lund Univ, Max Lab 4, 2 Fotongatan, S-22484 Lund, SwedenDugarov, Geser A.论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Inst Petr Geol & Geophys SB RAS, 3 Ac Koptyuga Ave, Novosibirsk 630090, Russia Lund Univ, Max Lab 4, 2 Fotongatan, S-22484 Lund, SwedenDuchkov, Anton A.论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Inst Petr Geol & Geophys SB RAS, 3 Ac Koptyuga Ave, Novosibirsk 630090, Russia Novosibirsk State Univ, 1 St Pirogova, Novosibirsk 630090, Russia Lund Univ, Max Lab 4, 2 Fotongatan, S-22484 Lund, SwedenFokin, Mikhail, I论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Inst Petr Geol & Geophys SB RAS, 3 Ac Koptyuga Ave, Novosibirsk 630090, Russia Lund Univ, Max Lab 4, 2 Fotongatan, S-22484 Lund, SwedenDrobchik, Arkady N.论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Inst Petr Geol & Geophys SB RAS, 3 Ac Koptyuga Ave, Novosibirsk 630090, Russia Lund Univ, Max Lab 4, 2 Fotongatan, S-22484 Lund, SwedenShevchenko, Pavel D.论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Argonne Natl Lab, Adv Photon Source, 9700 S Cass Ave, Lemont, IL 60439 USA Lund Univ, Max Lab 4, 2 Fotongatan, S-22484 Lund, SwedenDe Carlo, Francesco论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Argonne Natl Lab, Adv Photon Source, 9700 S Cass Ave, Lemont, IL 60439 USA Lund Univ, Max Lab 4, 2 Fotongatan, S-22484 Lund, SwedenMokso, Rajmund论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Lund Univ, Max Lab 4, 2 Fotongatan, S-22484 Lund, Sweden Lund Univ, Max Lab 4, 2 Fotongatan, S-22484 Lund, Sweden
- [26] Mechanical properties of clathrate hydrates: status and perspectives[J]. ENERGY & ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE, 2012, 5 (05) : 6779 - 6795Ning, Fulong论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: China Univ Geosci, Fac Engn, Wuhan 430074, Peoples R China China Univ Geosci, Fac Engn, Wuhan 430074, Peoples R ChinaYu, Yibing论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: China Univ Geosci, Fac Engn, Wuhan 430074, Peoples R China China Univ Geosci, Fac Engn, Wuhan 430074, Peoples R ChinaKjelstrup, Signe论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Norwegian Univ Sci & Technol, Dept Chem, N-95362 Trondheim, Norway Delft Univ Technol, Proc & Energy Lab, NL-2628 CA Delft, Netherlands China Univ Geosci, Fac Engn, Wuhan 430074, Peoples R ChinaVlugt, Thijs J. H.论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Delft Univ Technol, Proc & Energy Lab, NL-2628 CA Delft, Netherlands China Univ Geosci, Fac Engn, Wuhan 430074, Peoples R ChinaGlavatskiy, Kirill论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Norwegian Univ Sci & Technol, Dept Chem, N-95362 Trondheim, Norway China Univ Geosci, Fac Engn, Wuhan 430074, Peoples R China
- [27] Methane exploitation by carbon dioxide from gas hydrates - Phase equilibria for CO2-CH4 mixed hydrate system[J]. JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL ENGINEERING OF JAPAN, 1996, 29 (03) : 478 - 483Ohgaki, K论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Dept. of Chem. Eng., Osaka Univ., Toyonaka论文数: 引用数: h-index:机构:Sangawa, H论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Dept. of Chem. Eng., Osaka Univ., Toyonaka论文数: 引用数: h-index:机构:Nakano, S论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Dept. of Chem. Eng., Osaka Univ., Toyonaka
- [28] Enhanced CH4-CO2 Hydrate Swapping in the Presence of Low Dosage Methanol[J]. ENERGIES, 2020, 13 (20)Pandey, Jyoti Shanker论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Tech Univ Denmark, Dept Chem Engn, Ctr Energy Resource Engn CERE, DK-2800 Lyngby, Denmark Tech Univ Denmark, Dept Chem Engn, Ctr Energy Resource Engn CERE, DK-2800 Lyngby, DenmarkKarantonidis, Charilaos论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Tech Univ Denmark, Dept Chem Engn, Ctr Energy Resource Engn CERE, DK-2800 Lyngby, Denmark Tech Univ Denmark, Dept Chem Engn, Ctr Energy Resource Engn CERE, DK-2800 Lyngby, DenmarkKarcz, Adam Paul论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Tech Univ Denmark, Dept Energy Convers & Storage, Solid State Chem SSC, DK-2800 Lyngby, Denmark Tech Univ Denmark, Dept Chem Engn, Ctr Energy Resource Engn CERE, DK-2800 Lyngby, Denmarkvon Solms, Nicolas论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Tech Univ Denmark, Dept Chem Engn, Ctr Energy Resource Engn CERE, DK-2800 Lyngby, Denmark Tech Univ Denmark, Dept Chem Engn, Ctr Energy Resource Engn CERE, DK-2800 Lyngby, Denmark
- [29] From Microscale (400l) to Macroscale (425L): Experimental Investigations of the CO2/N2-CH4 Exchange in Gas Hydrates Simulating the Ignik Sikumi Field Trial[J]. JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SOLID EARTH, 2018, 123 (05) : 3608 - 3620Schicks, J. M.论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: GFZ German Res Ctr Geosci, Potsdam, Germany GFZ German Res Ctr Geosci, Potsdam, GermanyStrauch, B.论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: GFZ German Res Ctr Geosci, Potsdam, Germany GFZ German Res Ctr Geosci, Potsdam, GermanyHeeschen, K. U.论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: GFZ German Res Ctr Geosci, Potsdam, Germany GFZ German Res Ctr Geosci, Potsdam, GermanySpangenberg, E.论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: GFZ German Res Ctr Geosci, Potsdam, Germany GFZ German Res Ctr Geosci, Potsdam, GermanyLuzi-Helbing, M.论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: GFZ German Res Ctr Geosci, Potsdam, Germany GFZ German Res Ctr Geosci, Potsdam, Germany
- [30] Production-induced instability of a gentle submarine slope: Potential impact of gas hydrate exploitation with the huff-puff method[J]. ENGINEERING GEOLOGY, 2021, 289Tan, Lin论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Tongji Univ, State Key Lab Disaster Reduct Civil Engn, 1239 Siping Rd, Shanghai 200092, Peoples R China Tongji Univ, Minist Educ, Key Lab Geotech & Underground Engn, 1239 Siping Rd, Shanghai 200092, Peoples R China Tongji Univ, State Key Lab Disaster Reduct Civil Engn, 1239 Siping Rd, Shanghai 200092, Peoples R ChinaLiu, Fang论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Tongji Univ, State Key Lab Disaster Reduct Civil Engn, 1239 Siping Rd, Shanghai 200092, Peoples R China Tongji Univ, Minist Educ, Key Lab Geotech & Underground Engn, 1239 Siping Rd, Shanghai 200092, Peoples R China Tongji Univ, State Key Lab Disaster Reduct Civil Engn, 1239 Siping Rd, Shanghai 200092, Peoples R ChinaHuang, Yu论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Tongji Univ, Minist Educ, Key Lab Geotech & Underground Engn, 1239 Siping Rd, Shanghai 200092, Peoples R China Tongji Univ, State Key Lab Disaster Reduct Civil Engn, 1239 Siping Rd, Shanghai 200092, Peoples R ChinaCrosta, Giovanni论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Univ Milano Bicocca, Dept Earth & Environm Sci, Piazza Sci 4, I-20126 Milan, Italy Tongji Univ, State Key Lab Disaster Reduct Civil Engn, 1239 Siping Rd, Shanghai 200092, Peoples R ChinaFrattini, Paolo论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: Univ Milano Bicocca, Dept Earth & Environm Sci, Piazza Sci 4, I-20126 Milan, Italy Tongji Univ, State Key Lab Disaster Reduct Civil Engn, 1239 Siping Rd, Shanghai 200092, Peoples R ChinaCen, Xueqi论文数: 0 引用数: 0 h-index: 0机构: SINOPEC, Oil Explorat & Prod Res Inst, 5 Baisha Rd, Beijing, Peoples R China Tongji Univ, State Key Lab Disaster Reduct Civil Engn, 1239 Siping Rd, Shanghai 200092, Peoples R China