Impact of Substituting Meats with Plant-Based Analogues on Health-Related Markers: A Systematic Review of Human Intervention Studies

被引:2
作者
Del Bo', Cristian [1 ]
Chehade, Lara [1 ]
Tucci, Massimiliano [1 ]
Canclini, Federica [1 ]
Riso, Patrizia [1 ]
Martini, Daniela [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Milan, Dept Food Environm & Nutr Sci DeFENS, Div Human Nutr, I-20133 Milan, Italy
关键词
plant-based foods; meat alternatives; sustainable healthy diets; dietary intervention; ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS; DIET; MYCOPROTEIN; ADULTS;
D O I
10.3390/nu16152498
中图分类号
R15 [营养卫生、食品卫生]; TS201 [基础科学];
学科分类号
100403 ;
摘要
The growing drive towards more sustainable dietary patterns has led to an increased demand for and availability of plant-based meat analogues (PBMAs). This systematic review aims to summarize the currently available evidence from human intervention studies investigating the impact of substituting animal meat (AM) with PBMAs in adults. A total of 19 studies were included. Overall, an increase in satiety following PBMA intake was reported, albeit to different extents and not always accompanied by changes in leptin and ghrelin. PBMAs generally resulted in lower protein bioavailability and a smaller increase in plasma essential amino acids in comparison to AM. However, muscle protein synthesis and physical performance were not affected. Finally, conflicting results have been reported for other outcomes, such as pancreatic and gastrointestinal hormones, oxidative stress and inflammation, vascular function, and microbiota composition. In conclusion, we documented that the impact of substituting AM with PBMA products has been scarcely investigated. In addition, the heterogeneity found in terms of study design, population, outcomes, and findings suggests the need for additional high-quality intervention trials, particularly long-term ones, to better clarify the advantages and potential critical issues of such substitutions within sustainable healthy diets.
引用
收藏
页数:25
相关论文
共 64 条
[1]   Health effects of dietary risks in 195 countries, 1990-2017: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2017 [J].
Afshin, Ashkan ;
Sur, Patrick John ;
Fay, Kairsten A. ;
Cornaby, Leslie ;
Ferrara, Giannina ;
Salama, Joseph S. ;
Mullany, Erin C. ;
Abate, Kalkidan Hassen ;
Abbafati, Cristiana ;
Abebe, Zegeye ;
Afarideh, Mohsen ;
Aggarwal, Anju ;
Agrawal, Sutapa ;
Akinyemiju, Tomi ;
Alahdab, Fares ;
Bacha, Umar ;
Bachman, Victoria F. ;
Badali, Hamid ;
Badawi, Alaa ;
Bensenor, Isabela M. ;
Bernabe, Eduardo ;
Biryukov, Stan H. ;
Biadgilign, Sibhatu Kassa K. ;
Cahill, Leah E. ;
Carrero, Juan J. ;
Cercy, Kelly M. ;
Dandona, Lalit ;
Dandona, Rakhi ;
Anh Kim Dang ;
Degefa, Meaza Girma ;
Zaki, Maysaa El Sayed ;
Esteghamati, Alireza ;
Esteghamati, Sadaf ;
Fanzo, Jessica ;
Farinha, Carla Sofia E. Sa ;
Farvid, Maryam S. ;
Farzadfar, Farshad ;
Feigin, Valery L. ;
Fernandes, Joao C. ;
Flor, Luisa Sorio ;
Foigt, Nataliya A. ;
Forouzanfar, Mohammad H. ;
Ganji, Morsaleh ;
Geleijnse, Johanna M. ;
Gillum, Richard F. ;
Goulart, Alessandra C. ;
Grosso, Giuseppe ;
Guessous, Idris ;
Hamidi, Samer ;
Hankey, Graeme J. .
LANCET, 2019, 393 (10184) :1958-1972
[2]   Plant-Based Meat Alternatives: Technological, Nutritional, Environmental, Market, and Social Challenges and Opportunities [J].
Andreani, Giulia ;
Sogari, Giovanni ;
Marti, Alessandra ;
Froldi, Federico ;
Dagevos, Hans ;
Martini, Daniela .
NUTRIENTS, 2023, 15 (02)
[3]   Sensory properties and consumer acceptance of plant-based meat, dairy, fish and eggs analogs: a systematic review [J].
Appiani, Marta ;
Cattaneo, Camilla ;
Laureati, Monica .
FRONTIERS IN SUSTAINABLE FOOD SYSTEMS, 2023, 7
[4]   Can the Substitution of Milk with Plant-Based Drinks Affect Health-Related Markers? A Systematic Review of Human Intervention Studies in Adults [J].
Biscotti, Paola ;
Del Bo', Cristian ;
Carvalho, Catarina ;
Torres, Duarte ;
Reboul, Emmanuelle ;
Pellegrini, Beatrice ;
Vinelli, Valentina ;
Polito, Angela ;
Censi, Laura ;
Porrini, Marisa ;
Martini, Daniela ;
Riso, Patrizia .
NUTRIENTS, 2023, 15 (11)
[5]   Mycoprotein reduces energy intake and postprandial insulin release without altering glucagon-like peptide-1 and peptide tyrosine-tyrosine concentrations in healthy overweight and obese adults: a randomised-controlled trial [J].
Bottin, Jeanne H. ;
Swann, Jonathan R. ;
Cropp, Eleanor ;
Chambers, Edward S. ;
Ford, Heather E. ;
Ghatei, Mohammed A. ;
Frost, Gary S. .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF NUTRITION, 2016, 116 (02) :360-374
[6]   Nutritional Quality of Legumes, and Their Role in Cardiometabolic Risk Prevention: A Review [J].
Bouchenak, Malika ;
Lamri-Senhadji, Myriem .
JOURNAL OF MEDICINAL FOOD, 2013, 16 (03) :185-198
[7]   A Review of Healthy Dietary Choices for Cardiovascular Disease: From Individual Nutrients and Foods to Dietary Patterns [J].
Chen, Wenjing ;
Zhang, Shuqing ;
Hu, Xiaosong ;
Chen, Fang ;
Li, Daotong .
NUTRIENTS, 2023, 15 (23)
[8]  
Coelho MOC, 2021, BRIT J NUTR, V125, P147, DOI [10.1017/S0007114520002524, 10.1017/S0007114520002524[Opensinanewwindow]]
[9]   Comparative Assessment of the Nutritional Profile of Meat Products and Their Plant-Based Analogues [J].
Costa-Catala, Judit ;
Toro-Funes, Natalia ;
Comas-Baste, Oriol ;
Hernandez-Macias, Salvador ;
Sanchez-Perez, Sonia ;
Latorre-Moratalla, M. Luz ;
Veciana-Nogues, M. Teresa ;
Castell-Garralda, Victoria ;
Vidal-Carou, M. Carmen .
NUTRIENTS, 2023, 15 (12)
[10]   Assessing the effects of alternative plant-based meats v. animal meats on biomarkers of inflammation: a secondary analysis of the SWAP-MEAT randomized crossover trial [J].
Crimarco, Anthony ;
Landry, Matthew J. ;
Carter, Matthew M. ;
Gardner, Christopher D. .
JOURNAL OF NUTRITIONAL SCIENCE, 2022, 11