Comparison between arthroplasty and non-operative treatment for proximal humeral fractures: a systematic review and meta-analysis

被引:0
作者
Lai, Boyong [1 ]
Zhang, Sheng [1 ]
Pan, Junxi [1 ]
Li, An [1 ]
Guo, Ding [1 ]
Peng, Zhihua [1 ]
Feng, Qinghui [1 ]
机构
[1] Guangzhou Med Univ, Affiliated Tradit Chinese Med Hosp, Guangzhou, Peoples R China
关键词
arthroplasty; reverse shoulder arthroplasty; hemiarthroplasty; non-surgical treatment; functions; complications; TOTAL SHOULDER ARTHROPLASTY; 4-PART FRACTURES; ELDERLY-PATIENTS; NONSURGICAL TREATMENT; SURGICAL-MANAGEMENT; DECISION-MAKING; HEMIARTHROPLASTY; MORTALITY; OLDER; EPIDEMIOLOGY;
D O I
10.3389/fmed.2024.1436000
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Background: The clinical efficacy of reverse shoulder arthroplasty (RSA), hemiarthroplasty (HA), and non-surgical management in the treatment of proximal humeral fractures (PHFs) is inconclusive. This systematic review and meta-analysis compared the clinical outcomes of arthroplasty and non-surgical management of PHFs. Methods: The databases of PubMed, Embase, Web of Science, and Cochrane Library were searched on 5 May 2023 for studies comparing arthroplasty and non-surgical treatment of PHFs. Both randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and non-randomized controlled trials (nRCTs), were included. Standard methodological quality assessments were conducted for both types of studies. The primary outcome was the Constant-Murley Score (CMS) after surgical or non-surgical treatment. Secondary study outcomes included the visual analog scale (VAS), range of motion, and complications. All functional scores and complications were subjected to subgroup and sensitivity analyses. Results: A total of four RCTs and six nRCTs were included in this study, which provided 508 patients in total for meta-analysis: 238 treated with arthroplasty and 270 treated non-surgically, of which 83 were treated with HA and 155 with RSA. All relevant information was collected, including functional scores, VAS, range of motion, and complications. The study found no significant difference in functional outcomes (mean difference, 2.82; 95% confidence interval, -0.49 to 6.14; P = 0.10; I-2 = 77%) and complications (mean difference, 1.08; 95% confidence interval, 0.51-2.25; P = 0.85; I-2 = 47%) between arthroplasty and non-surgical treatment. Both RCTs and nRCTs showed the same results. However, VAS scores were significantly lower in surgical treatment compared to non-surgical treatment. Subgroup and sensitivity analyses showed that RSA could achieve better functional scores than non-surgical treatment (mean difference, 6.00; 95% confidence interval, 1.97-10.03; P = 0.004; I-2 = 0%), while the results for HA were not significant (P > 0.05). Conclusion: There were no significant differences in complications between arthroplasty and non-surgical treatment for PHFs. RSA could achieve better functional results than non-surgical treatment, while HA could only achieve better forward flexion.
引用
收藏
页数:9
相关论文
共 48 条
[1]   Reverse shoulder arthroplasty for proximal humeral fractures: update on indications, technique, and results [J].
Acevedo, Daniel C. ;
VanBeek, Corinne ;
Lazarus, Mark D. ;
Williams, Gerald R. ;
Abboud, Joseph A. .
JOURNAL OF SHOULDER AND ELBOW SURGERY, 2014, 23 (02) :279-289
[2]  
Amin SJ., 2022, Seminars Arthrop: JSES, V32, P312, DOI [10.1053/j.sart.2021.11.003, DOI 10.1053/J.SART.2021.11.003]
[3]   Management of Proximal Humerus Fractures in Adults-A Scoping Review [J].
Baker, Hayden P. ;
Gutbrod, Joseph ;
Strelzow, Jason A. ;
Maassen, Nicholas H. ;
Shi, Lewis .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL MEDICINE, 2022, 11 (20)
[4]   Operative versus nonoperative treatment of proximal humeral fractures: a systematic review, meta-analysis, and comparison of observational studies and randomized controlled trials [J].
Beks, Reinier B. ;
Ochen, Yassine ;
Frima, Herman ;
Smeeing, Diederik P. J. ;
van der Meijden, Olivier ;
Timmers, Tim K. ;
van der Velde, Detlef ;
van Heijl, Mark ;
Leenen, Luke P. H. ;
Groenwold, Rolf H. H. ;
Houwert, R. Marijn .
JOURNAL OF SHOULDER AND ELBOW SURGERY, 2018, 27 (08) :1526-1534
[5]   Mortality after a proximal humeral fracture DATA ON 18,452 PATIENTS FROM THE SWEDISH FRACTURE REGISTER [J].
Bergdahl, C. ;
Wennergren, D. ;
Ekelund, J. ;
Moller, M. .
BONE & JOINT JOURNAL, 2020, 102B (11) :1484-1490
[6]   Hemiarthroplasty for Humeral Four-part Fractures for Patients 65 Years and Older A Randomized Controlled Trial [J].
Boons, Harm W. ;
Goosen, Jon H. ;
van Grinsven, Susan ;
van Susante, Job L. ;
van Loon, Corne J. .
CLINICAL ORTHOPAEDICS AND RELATED RESEARCH, 2012, 470 (12) :3483-3491
[7]   Epidemiology and trends in management of acute proximal humeral fractures in adults: an observational study of 137,436 cases from the Danish National Patient Register, 1996-2018 [J].
Brorson, Stig ;
Viberg, Bjarke ;
Gundtoft, Per ;
Jalal, Bamo ;
Ohrt-Nissen, Soren .
ACTA ORTHOPAEDICA, 2022, 93 :750-755
[8]   Surgeons agree more on treatment recommendations than on classification of proximal humeral fractures [J].
Brorson, Stig ;
Olsen, Bo Sanderhoff ;
Frich, Lars Henrik ;
Jensen, Steen Lund ;
Sorensen, Anne Kathrine ;
Krogsgaard, Michael ;
Hrobjartsson, Asbjorn .
BMC MUSCULOSKELETAL DISORDERS, 2012, 13
[9]   Effectiveness and Safety of Interventions for Treating Adults with Displaced Proximal Humeral Fracture: A Network Meta-Analysis and Systematic Review [J].
Chen, Long ;
Xing, Fei ;
Xiang, Zhou .
PLOS ONE, 2016, 11 (11)
[10]   Three- and four-part displaced proximal humeral fractures in patients older than 70 years: reverse shoulder arthroplasty or nonsurgical treatment? [J].
Chivot, Matthieu ;
Lami, Damien ;
Bizzozero, Paul ;
Galland, Alexandre ;
Argenson, Jean-Noel .
JOURNAL OF SHOULDER AND ELBOW SURGERY, 2019, 28 (02) :252-259