Pathways to leadership: what accounts for women's (in)equitable career paths in the health sectors in India and Kenya? A scoping review

被引:2
作者
Saville, Naomi M. [1 ,2 ]
Uppal, Radhika [3 ]
Odunga, Sally Atieno [4 ]
Kedia, Sapna [3 ]
Odero, Henry Owoko [4 ]
Tanaka, Sonja [2 ]
Kiwuwa-Muyingo, Sylvia [4 ]
Eleh, Lawrence [2 ]
Venkatesh, Sucharitha [3 ]
Zeinali, Zahra [2 ]
Koay, Aaron [2 ]
Buse, Kent [2 ]
Verma, Ravi [3 ]
Hawkes, Sarah [2 ]
机构
[1] UCL, Inst Global Hlth, London, England
[2] Global Hlth 50-50, Cambridge, England
[3] ICRW, New Delhi, India
[4] APHRC, Nairobi, Kenya
来源
BMJ GLOBAL HEALTH | 2024年 / 9卷 / 07期
基金
比尔及梅琳达.盖茨基金会;
关键词
Health policy; Decision Making; Health systems; India; Kenya; GENDER; BARRIERS;
D O I
10.1136/bmjgh-2023-014745
中图分类号
R1 [预防医学、卫生学];
学科分类号
1004 ; 120402 ;
摘要
Objectives We aimed to capture evidence on enablers and barriers to improving equal opportunity and effective organisational interventions that can advance women's leadership in India and Kenya's health sectors.Methods We systematically searched JSTOR, PubMed, SCOPUS and Web of Science databases, reference lists of selected articles and Google Scholar using string searches. We included studies that were published in English from 2000 to 2022 in peer-reviewed journals or grey literature, focused on paid, formal health professionals in India or Kenya, described factors relating to women's representation/leadership.Results We identified 26 studies, 15 from India and 11 from Kenya. From each country, seven studies focused on nursing. Participants included women and men health sector workers. Seven studies used mixed methods, 11 were qualitative, 5 were quantitative and 3 were commentaries. Factors influencing women's career progression at individual/interpersonal levels included family support, personal attributes (knowledge/skills) and material resources. Factors at the organisational level included capacity strengthening, networking, organisational policies, gender quotas, work culture and relationships, flexibility, and work burden. Nursing studies identified verbal/sexual harassment and professional hierarchies as barriers to career progression. Structural barriers included a lack of infrastructure (training institutes and acceptable working environments). Normative themes included occupational segregation by gender (particularly in nursing), unpaid care work burden for women and gender norms. Studies of interventions to improve women's career progression and sex-disaggregated workforce data in India or Kenya were limited, especially on leadership within career pathways. The evidence focuses on enablers and barriers at work, rather than on organisations/systems to support women's leadership or address gender norms.Results We identified 26 studies, 15 from India and 11 from Kenya. From each country, seven studies focused on nursing. Participants included women and men health sector workers. Seven studies used mixed methods, 11 were qualitative, 5 were quantitative and 3 were commentaries. Factors influencing women's career progression at individual/interpersonal levels included family support, personal attributes (knowledge/skills) and material resources. Factors at the organisational level included capacity strengthening, networking, organisational policies, gender quotas, work culture and relationships, flexibility, and work burden. Nursing studies identified verbal/sexual harassment and professional hierarchies as barriers to career progression. Structural barriers included a lack of infrastructure (training institutes and acceptable working environments). Normative themes included occupational segregation by gender (particularly in nursing), unpaid care work burden for women and gender norms. Studies of interventions to improve women's career progression and sex-disaggregated workforce data in India or Kenya were limited, especially on leadership within career pathways. The evidence focuses on enablers and barriers at work, rather than on organisations/systems to support women's leadership or address gender norms.Conclusions Women in India and Kenya's health sectors face multiple impediments in their careers, which impact their advancement to leadership. This calls for gender-transformative interventions to tackle discrimination/harassment, provide targeted training/mentorship, better parental leave/benefits, flexible/remote working, family/coworker support and equal-opportunity policies/legislation.
引用
收藏
页码:1 / 20
页数:20
相关论文
共 60 条
  • [1] Gender and Feminization in Health Care Professions
    Adams, Tracey L.
    [J]. SOCIOLOGY COMPASS, 2010, 4 (07): : 454 - 465
  • [2] [Anonymous], 1949, Central government act: article 15 in the Constitution of India
  • [3] Informing the scale-up of Kenya's nursing workforce: a mixed methods study of factors affecting pre-service training capacity and production
    Appiagyei, Ashley A.
    Kiriinya, Rose N.
    Gross, Jessica M.
    Wambua, David N.
    Oywer, Elizabeth O.
    Kamenju, Andrew K.
    Higgins, Melinda K.
    Riley, Patricia L.
    Rogers, Martha F.
    [J]. HUMAN RESOURCES FOR HEALTH, 2014, 12
  • [4] Aromataris E., 2024, JBI
  • [5] India's one million Accredited Social Health Activists (ASHA) win the Global Health Leaders award at the 75th World Health Assembly: Time to move beyond rhetoric to action?
    Asthana, Sumegha
    Mayra, Kaveri
    [J]. LANCET REGIONAL HEALTH - SOUTHEAST ASIA, 2022, 3
  • [6] Bhadra Mita., 2011, Indian Anthropologist, V41, P17
  • [7] Bowen G, 2021, Strategy, Leadership, and AI in the Cyber Ecosystem, P23
  • [8] Bronfenbrenner U., 1981, The ecology of human development: Experiments by nature and design, DOI DOI 10.4159/9780674028845
  • [9] Buse K., 2024, BMJ
  • [10] Reducing Gender Disparity in Oncologists in India: An Opportunity to Address Workforce Challenges
    Chopra, S.
    Viswanathan, A.
    Mittal, P.
    Laskar, S. G.
    Reddy, V. A.
    Nair, R.
    Bajpai, J.
    Chaukar, D.
    Gupta, S.
    Cruz, A. D.
    Badwe, R.
    [J]. CLINICAL ONCOLOGY, 2018, 30 (12) : 805 - 809