Network Context and the Effectiveness of International Agreements

被引:1
作者
Kinne, Brandon J. [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Calif Davis, Polit Sci, Davis, CA 95616 USA
关键词
INTERGOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS; POLICY CONVERGENCE; COMMUNITY STRUCTURE; REGIME COMPLEX; COOPERATION; ALLIANCES; TREATIES; MODELS; TRADE; GLOBALIZATION;
D O I
10.1093/isq/sqae099
中图分类号
D81 [国际关系];
学科分类号
030207 ;
摘要
Why do some international agreements yield more cooperation than others? I argue that the network context of agreements conditions their effectiveness. I focus on bilateral defense cooperation agreements (DCAs), which promote defense activities like joint military exercises, peacekeeping, arms trade, and the sharing of classified information. Because DCAs emphasize ongoing cooperative actions, they offer an ideal setting to assess treaty effectiveness. The analysis shows that when agreements are embedded in transitive "friend of friend" relations, characterized by extensive ties to common third parties, they generate higher levels of cooperation. I argue that this network effect is the result of policy convergence. When states share ties with common third parties, their own policies become more closely aligned, and this alignment in turn reduces the costs and increases the benefits of cooperative actions. The theory and findings developed here apply to a wide array of cooperative interactions across multiple issue areas. The effectiveness of international agreements depends on network context. ?Por qu & eacute; algunos acuerdos internacionales dan como resultado una mayor cooperaci & oacute;n que otros? Argumentamos que el contexto a nivel de redes de los acuerdos condiciona su efectividad. Nos centramos en el estudio de los acuerdos bilaterales de cooperaci & oacute;n en materia de defensa (DCA, por sus siglas en ingl & eacute;s), los cuales promueven actividades de defensa, tales como ejercicios militares conjuntos, operaciones de mantenimiento de la paz, comercio de armas e intercambio de informaci & oacute;n confidencial. Los DCA, por el hecho de poner de relieve las acciones de cooperaci & oacute;n en curso, ofrecen un entorno ideal para evaluar la eficacia de los tratados. Concluimos que, cuando estos acuerdos est & aacute;n relacionados con relaciones transitivas de tipo "amigo de un amigo" caracterizadas por amplios v & iacute;nculos con terceros comunes, generan niveles m & aacute;s altos de cooperaci & oacute;n. Argumentamos que este efecto de redes es el resultado de la convergencia de pol & iacute;ticas. Cuando los Estados comparten v & iacute;nculos con terceros comunes, sus propias pol & iacute;ticas tienden a alinearse m & aacute;s estrechamente. Esta alineaci & oacute;n, a su vez, reduce los costes y aumenta los beneficios de las acciones cooperativas. La teor & iacute;a y las conclusiones que desarrollamos en este art & iacute;culo son potencialmente aplicables a una amplia gama de interacciones cooperativas, m & aacute;s all & aacute; de los acuerdos de defensa. La eficacia de los acuerdos internacionales depende del contexto de las redes. Pourquoi certains accords internationaux g & eacute;n & egrave;rent-ils plus de coop & eacute;ration que d'autres? J'affirme que le contexte du r & eacute;seau des accords conditionne leur efficacit & eacute;. Je me concentre sur les accords de coop & eacute;ration de d & eacute;fense (ACD) bilat & eacute;raux, qui promeuvent des activit & eacute;s de d & eacute;fense comme des exercices militaires conjoints, des op & eacute;rations de maintien de la paix, du commerce d'armes et le partage d'informations classifi & eacute;es. Comme les ACD accentuent les mesures de coop & eacute;ration en cours, ils pr & eacute;sentent un cadre id & eacute;al pour l'& eacute;valuation de l'efficacit & eacute; des trait & eacute;s. J'observe que lorsque les accords s'inscrivent dans des relations transitives " d'ami d'ami ", caract & eacute;ris & eacute;es par des liens importants avec des m & ecirc;mes tiers, ils g & eacute;n & egrave;rent des liens de coop & eacute;ration sup & eacute;rieurs. J'affirme que cet effet de r & eacute;seau r & eacute;sulte de la convergence politique. Quand les & Eacute;tats partagent des liens avec des m & ecirc;mes tiers, leurs politiques s'alignent fortement, et cet alignement r & eacute;duit ensuite les co & ucirc;ts et augmente les avantages des mesures de coop & eacute;ration. La th & eacute;orie d & eacute;velopp & eacute;e et les r & eacute;sultats obtenus ici pourraient s'appliquer & agrave; un large & eacute;ventail d'interactions de coop & eacute;ration, qui vont au-del & agrave; des accords de d & eacute;fense. L'efficacit & eacute; des accords internationaux d & eacute;pend du contexte du r & eacute;seau.
引用
收藏
页数:15
相关论文
共 127 条
  • [1] Angrist JD, 2009, MOSTLY HARMLESS ECONOMETRICS: AN EMPIRICISTS COMPANION, P1
  • [2] Antonopoulos P, 2017, DEF SECUR ANAL, V33, P366, DOI 10.1080/14751798.2017.1379119
  • [3] Cumulative effects of triadic closure and homophily in social networks
    Asikainen, Aili
    Iniguez, Gerardo
    Urena-Carrion, Javier
    Kaski, Kimmo
    Kivela, Mikko
    [J]. SCIENCE ADVANCES, 2020, 6 (19)
  • [4] Transgovernmental Networks and Domestic Policy Convergence: Evidence from Insider Trading Regulation
    Bach, David
    Newman, Abraham L.
    [J]. INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATION, 2010, 64 (03) : 505 - 528
  • [5] Do free trade agreements actually increase members' international trade?
    Baier, Scott L.
    Bergstrand, Jeffrey H.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL ECONOMICS, 2007, 71 (01) : 72 - 95
  • [6] Estimating Dynamic State Preferences from United Nations Voting Data
    Bailey, Michael A.
    Strezhnev, Anton
    Voeten, Erik
    [J]. JOURNAL OF CONFLICT RESOLUTION, 2017, 61 (02) : 430 - 456
  • [7] Competing for Scarce Foreign Capital: Spatial Dependence in the Diffusion of Double Taxation Treaties
    Barthel, Fabian
    Neumayer, Eric
    [J]. INTERNATIONAL STUDIES QUARTERLY, 2012, 56 (04) : 645 - 660
  • [8] Hierarchy and the Provision of Order in International Politics
    Beardsley, Kyle
    Liu, Howard
    Mucha, Peter J.
    Siegel, David A.
    Tellez, Juan F.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF POLITICS, 2020, 82 (02) : 731 - 746
  • [9] Defense innovation, technology transfers and public policy
    Bellais, R
    Guichard, R
    [J]. DEFENCE AND PEACE ECONOMICS, 2006, 17 (03) : 273 - 286
  • [10] REVIEW ARTICLE - WHAT IS POLICY CONVERGENCE AND WHAT CAUSES IT
    BENNETT, CJ
    [J]. BRITISH JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE, 1991, 21 : 215 - 233