Climate Change as Unjust Enrichment

被引:0
作者
Gilboa, Maytal [1 ]
Kaplan, Yotam [2 ]
Sarel, Roee [3 ]
机构
[1] Bar Ilan Univ, Fac Law, Ramat Gan, Israel
[2] Hebrew Univ Jerusalem, Law Sch, Jerusalem, Israel
[3] Univ Hamburg, Inst Law & Econ, Private Law & Law & Econ, Hamburg, Germany
基金
欧洲研究理事会;
关键词
SEA-LEVEL RISE; DISGORGEMENT REMEDY; PARIS AGREEMENT; PUBLIC CHOICE; RESTITUTION; LAW; DAMAGES; JUSTICE; NEGLIGENCE; GOVERNMENT;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
D9 [法律]; DF [法律];
学科分类号
0301 ;
摘要
The climate crisis is the most significant challenge of our generation, with no satisfactory legal response in sight. Political polarization and influence from special interest groups have hindered effective regulatory action on both national and international fronts. Climate litigation through the court system, primarily based on tort principles, has also been largely unsuccessful. In response to these legal failures, some courts and commentators have suggested that the law of unjust enrichment may provide the correct legal framework for addressing the climate crisis. This Article is the first to offer a general legal framework of climate change as unjust enrichment. This analysis is a necessary first step toward the adoption and success of unjust enrichment claims in climate litigation. The Article provides a doctrinal and normative assessment of this legal innovation. First, doctrinally, we highlight some advantages of unjust enrichment doctrine as a vehicle for climate litigation. Mainly, a tort claim must be based on a clear showing of harm. This requirement is difficult to satisfy in climate litigation, which is based mostly on future, abstract, and highly dispersed harms. Conversely, a claim of unjust enrichment does not necessitate direct proof of harm but focuses on the unjust gains of the defendant. While the worst harms of climate change lie in the future, strong commercial actors benefit here and now. Second, normatively, we highlight the compatibility of enrichment-based liability with the goals of climate litigation. If pollution remains profitable, it would be na & imath;<spacing diaeresis>ve to anticipate any significant progress in mitigating climate change. By making it possible to take away unjust gains, the law of unjust enrichment can offer a remedy that addresses this key feature of the crisis. The Article also outlines the outer boundaries of liability in unjust enrichment and explains the conditions under which it should and should not apply. Defining a narrow scope of liability helps provide a tailored legal response, one that can be utilized by courts without overburdening defendants. Note that our goal is not to replace existing legal frameworks nor to offer unjust enrichment as a comprehensive and exclusive solution to the climate crisis. Rather, we aim to draw attention to this important option, hitherto understudied in legal scholarship and underutilized in practice, and to highlight some of its possible advantages.
引用
收藏
页码:1039 / 1094
页数:56
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] Climate Change Litigation
    Peel, Jacqueline
    Osofsky, Hari M.
    ANNUAL REVIEW OF LAW AND SOCIAL SCIENCE, VOL 16, 2020, 16 : 21 - 38
  • [42] Climate Change Injustice
    Francis, Blake
    ENVIRONMENTAL ETHICS, 2022, 44 (01) : 5 - 24
  • [43] Criminality and climate change
    White, Rob
    NATURE CLIMATE CHANGE, 2016, 6 (08) : 737 - 739
  • [44] Coal and climate change
    Edwards, Gareth A. S.
    WILEY INTERDISCIPLINARY REVIEWS-CLIMATE CHANGE, 2019, 10 (05)
  • [45] Climate change and society
    Betts, Alan K.
    AIMS GEOSCIENCES, 2021, 7 (02): : 194 - 218
  • [46] Is climate change ungovernable?
    Edwards, Paul N.
    LONDON REVIEW OF INTERNATIONAL LAW, 2024, : 351 - 372
  • [47] Climate change and interconnected risks to sustainable development in the Mediterranean
    Cramer, Wolfgang
    Guiot, Joel
    Fader, Marianela
    Garrabou, Joaquim
    Gattuso, Jean-Pierre
    Iglesias, Ana
    Lange, Manfred A.
    Lionello, Piero
    Carmen Llasat, Maria
    Paz, Shlomit
    Penuelas, Josep
    Snoussi, Maria
    Toreti, Andrea
    Tsimplis, Michael N.
    Xoplaki, Elena
    NATURE CLIMATE CHANGE, 2018, 8 (11) : 972 - 980
  • [48] Norms for the Earth: Changing the Climate on "Climate Change"
    Mitchell, Ronald B.
    Carpenter, Charli
    JOURNAL OF GLOBAL SECURITY STUDIES, 2019, 4 (04) : 413 - 429
  • [49] Climate justice without freedom: Assessing legal and political responses to climate change and forced migration
    Skillington, Tracey
    EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF SOCIAL THEORY, 2015, 18 (03) : 288 - 307
  • [50] Unjust punishment in organizations
    Mooijman, Marlon
    Graham, Jesse
    RESEARCH IN ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOR: AN ANNUAL SERIES OF ANALYTICAL ESSAYS AND CRITICAL REVIEWS, VOL 38, 2018, 38 : 95 - 106