Effect of concrete strength on the seismic performance of circular reinforced concrete columns confined by basalt and carbon fiber-reinforced polymer

This paper investigated the effect of concrete strength on the seismic performance of circular reinforced concrete (RC) columns confined by basalt and carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (BFRP and CFRP). Eight confined columns and four control columns were tested under a low cyclic lateral load. The variables in the test included concrete compressive strength (i.e., 22.4 MPa, 31.4 MPa, 42.5 MPa and 57.8 MPa) and FRP type (i.e., basalt and carbon fiber). The test results demonstrated that all the columns exhibited flexural failure after confinement. The strength, ductility and energy dissipation capacity of the confined columns were effectively enhanced. With the same confining stress, the peak loads of the BFRP- and CFRP-confined columns were nearly the same. However, the BFRP-confined columns with low and moderate concrete strength showed larger ductility and energy dissipation capacity compared with the CFRP-confined counterparts, and these capacities of the CFRP-confined column with a concrete strength of 57.8 MPa were slightly better than those of the BFRP-confined equivalent. This showed that the FRP jackets with larger modulus had better confinement effect on the columns with higher concrete strength. Finally, formulas for calculating the load carrying and ductility capacities of different FRPconfined circular RC columns were proposed based on the experimental results.