Heterogeneity of HPV16 virus-like particles indicates a complex assembly energy surface

Human Papillomavirus serotype 16 (HPV16) capsid protein (L1) pentamers canonically assemble into T = 7 icosahedral capsids. Such virus-like particles are the basis of the HPV vaccine. We examined assembly of L1 pentamers in response to pH, mild oxidants, and ionic strength and found a mixture of closed, roughly spherical structures from similar to 20 to similar to 70 nm in diameter, indicating the presence of many kinetically accessible energy minima. Using bulk and single particle techniques we observed that the size distribution changes but does not reach homogeneity. Though heterogenous in size, particles showed uniform responses to low ionic strength dissociation, thermal unfolding, and susceptibility to protease digestion. These assays suggest maturation over time, but at different rates. Cysteine oxidation further stabilized particles at early, but not late, times without changing general characteristics including thermal stability and protease digestion. These data show complex assembly paths to species of different sizes, but with locally similar interactions.