Results of a dilatancy round robin

The critical state approach currently finds widespread adoption in geotechnical engineering practice, particularly with respect to tailings storage facilities (TSFs). The laboratory component of such works usually involves determination of the critical state line (CSL) followed by stress- and state- dilatancy behaviour in triaxial compression conditions, characterised by the volumetric coupling parameter Ntc and the state dilatancy constant chi tc. While the reliability of CSL testing using current state of practice methods has been recently demonstrated, it is currently unclear how reproducibly Ntc and chi tc can be obtained. To investigate this, a dilatancy round robin program was carried out by five laboratories who regularly carry out such testing. In the first stage of the program, each laboratory adopted a version of "densification in layers", either dense moist tamping (DMT) or vibration-densification. While a generally consistent Ntc was observed, significant variation in chi tc was seen. To further investigate this variation, a second stage was carried out where slurry deposition (SD) and the "air dried" (AD) technique were used. These techniques showed better agreement between laboratories, while also producing lower values of chi tc than densification in layers. Some potential implications of these observations on current tailings engineering laboratory testing practice are outlined.