Non-operative management of metacarpal II-IV fractures: A retrospective study from a tertiary hand unit

Metacarpal fractures produce significant hand disability, and non-operative management of these fractures can produce satisfactory functional outcomes with few complications. However, most studies assessing non-operative outcomes of metacarpal fractures revolves around metacarpals I and V, which possess different anatomy. Therefore, further investigation into outcomes after non-operative treatment of metacarpals II-IV is required to inform management decisions and allow modification of the rehabilitation protocols to specific fracture patterns. All records for 76 non-operative patients presenting with fractures of metacarpals II-IV to our tertiary centre in the year 2019 were retrospectively reviewed. Patients were treated with thermoplastic splinting or fibreglass casting with a rehabilitative exercise programme. Range of motion (ROM) of the Metacarpophalangeal (MCPJ), Proximal Interphalangeal (PIPJ), and Distal Interphalangeal joints (DIPJ), return to work time, and complications were assessed at 12 weeks post-treatment. Mean return to work time was 5.4 weeks, and patients did not report any serious adverse events; the main complication reported was tenderness on palpation (20%). The MCPJ exhibited the poorest ROM (9 degrees flexion reduction relative to the healthy hand). Metacarpal II fractures were associated with significantly worse MCPJ flexion than metacarpal III (p = 0.022) and metacarpal IV (p = 0.049) fractures. Fractures of the metacarpal base were associated with superior MCPJ flexion (p = 0.004) but longer return to work time (p = 0.042) than head fractures. Spiral fractures were associated with shorter return to work time (p = 0.043) and superior ROM results (p = 0.041).