Performance of CT With Adrenal-Washout Protocol in Heterogeneous Adrenal Nodules: A Multiinstitutional Study

BACKGROUND. CT with adrenal-washout protocol (hereafter, adrenal-protocol CT) is commonly performed to distinguish adrenal adenomas from other adrenal tumors. However, the technique's utility among heterogeneous nodules is not well established, and the optimal method for placing ROIs in heterogeneous nodules is not clearly defined. OBJECTIVE. The purpose of our study was to determine the diagnostic performance of adrenal-protocol CT to distinguish adenomas from nonadenomas among heterogeneous adrenal nodules and to compare this performance among different methods for ROI placement. METHODS. This retrospective study included 164 patients (mean age, 59.1 years; 61 men, 103 women) with a total of 164 heterogeneous adrenal nodules evaluated using adrenal-protocol CT at seven institutions. All nodules had an available pathologic reference standard. A single investigator at each institution evaluated the CT images. ROIs were placed on portal venous phase images using four ROI methods: standard ROI, which refers to a single large ROI in the nodule's center; high ROI, a single ROI on the nodule's highest-attenuation area; low ROI, a single ROI the on nodule's lowest-attenuation area; and average ROI, the mean of the three ROIs on the nodule's superior, middle, and inferior thirds using the approach for the standard ROI. ROIs were then placed in identical locations on unenhanced and delayed phase images. Absolute washout was determined for all methods. RESULTS. The nodules comprised 82 adenomas and 82 nonadenomas (36 pheochromocytomas, 20 metastases, 12 adrenocortical carcinomas, and 14 nodules with other pathologies). The mean nodule size was 4.5 +/- 2.8 (SD) cm (range, 1.6-23.0 cm). Unenhanced CT attenuation of 10 HU or less exhibited sensitivity and specificity for adenoma of 22.0% and 96.3% for standard-ROI, 11.0% and 98.8% for high-ROI, 58.5% and 84.1% for low-ROI, and 30.5% and 97.6% for average-ROI methods. Adrenal-protocol CT overall (unenhanced attenuation <= 10 HU or absolute washout of >= 60%) exhibited sensitivity and specificity for adenoma of 57.3% and 84.1% for the standard-ROI method, 63.4% and 51.2% for the high-ROI method, 68.3% and 62.2% for the low-ROI method, and 59.8% and 85.4% for the average-ROI method. CONCLUSION. Adrenal-protocol CT has poor diagnostic performance for distinguishing adenomas from nonadenomas among heterogeneous adrenal nodules regardless of the method used for ROI placement. CLINICAL IMPACT. Adrenal-protocol CT has limited utility in the evaluation of heterogeneous adrenal nodules.