Lessons learned and policy implications from 20 years of Swiss agricultural policy reforms: A review of policy evaluations

被引:10
作者
Huber, Robert [1 ]
El Benni, Nadja [2 ]
Finger, Robert [1 ]
机构
[1] Swiss Fed Inst Technol, Agr Econ & Policy, Zurich, Switzerland
[2] Fed Res Stn Agroscope, Tknikon, Switzerland
来源
BIO-BASED AND APPLIED ECONOMICS | 2024年 / 13卷 / 02期
关键词
agricultural policy; comparative studies; policy comparison; policy evaluation; agriculture and food policy; farm support; AGRI-ENVIRONMENT SCHEME; GREENHOUSE-GAS EMISSIONS; LAND-USE; SWITZERLAND; FARM; EU; PAYMENTS; QUALITY; INCOME; COSTS;
D O I
10.36253/bae-14214
中图分类号
F [经济];
学科分类号
02 ;
摘要
Learning from the experiences of other countries can support efforts to improve agricultural policies. Switzerland provides an interesting case because its policy is exceptionally targeted towards the establishment of sustainable production systems. We describe the history and the current state of Swiss agricultural policy, review evaluations of policy reforms, summarise their impact and outline the lessons learned for policy developments in other countries. We discuss four implications: i) some goals have been met, albeit at a high cost, and so, increasing efficiency of policies is key; H) there is a need for more coherence and coordination regarding the different policy programmes (i.e. in the sense of a `food system policy'); Hi) cross-compliance measures (i.e. minimum standards for receiving support) have an important leverage effect; and iv) policy differentiation (e.g. by spatial targeting) and increasing farmers' discretion over how to achieve goals (e.g. by implementing results-based payments) are key for future policies.
引用
收藏
页码:121 / 146
页数:26
相关论文
共 154 条
[91]   Determinants for the Implementation of Action-, Result- and Multi-Actor-Oriented Agri-Environment Schemes in Switzerland [J].
Mack, Gabriele ;
Ritzel, Christian ;
Jan, Pierrick .
ECOLOGICAL ECONOMICS, 2020, 176
[92]   Determinants of the perceived administrative transaction costs caused by the uptake of an agri-environmental program [J].
Mack, Gabriele ;
Kohler, Andreas ;
Heitkaemper, Katja ;
El-Benni, Nadja .
JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT, 2019, 62 (10) :1802-1819
[93]   Short- and Long-Run Policy Evaluation: Support for Grassland-Based Milk Production in Switzerland [J].
Mack, Gabriele ;
Kohler, Andreas .
JOURNAL OF AGRICULTURAL ECONOMICS, 2019, 70 (01) :215-240
[94]   On-farm compliance costs and N surplus reduction of mixed dairy farms under grassland-based feeding systems [J].
Mack, Gabriele ;
Huber, Robert .
AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS, 2017, 154 :34-44
[95]  
Mann S., 2003, Eurochoices, V2, P32, DOI 10.1111/j.1746-692X.2003.tb00060.x
[96]  
Mann S., 2004, FAT-Schriftenreihe, V64
[97]   Why is agricultural policy not more environmentally ambitious? Comparing failed attempts in Switzerland [J].
Mann, Stefan ;
Kaiser, Antonia .
RESOURCES ENVIRONMENT AND SUSTAINABILITY, 2023, 11
[98]   Landscape quality payments in Switzerland: The congruence between policy and preferences [J].
Mann, Stefan ;
Hunziker, Marcel ;
Torregroza, Lina ;
Wartmann, Flurina ;
Kienast, Felix ;
Schuepbach, Beatrice .
JOURNAL OF POLICY MODELING, 2023, 45 (02) :251-265
[99]   Happy Tinbergen: Switzerland's New Direct Payment System [J].
Mann, Stefan ;
Lanz, Simon .
EUROCHOICES, 2013, 12 (03) :24-28
[100]  
Mann S, 2010, AGRARFORSCH SCHWEIZ+, V1, P24