Plato's Phaedo on Disagreement and Its Role in Epistemic Improvement

被引:0
作者
Seferoglu, Tonguc [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Ardahan, Ardahan, Turkey
来源
ANCIENT PHILOSOPHY TODAY: DIALOGOI | 2020年 / 2卷 / 01期
关键词
Plato; Phaedo; dialogue form; dogmatism; epistemic modesty; disagreement;
D O I
10.3366/anph.2020.0023
中图分类号
N09 [自然科学史]; B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ; 010108 ; 060207 ; 060305 ; 0712 ;
摘要
Recent studies suggest that the form and style of Plato's dialogues have significant associations with their philosophical contents. Few scholars, however, have focused on the role of disagreements in epistemic improvement within the context of Plato's Phaedo. This paper seeks to unearth a 'theory of disagreement' underpinning the Phaedo by examining the conversation between Socrates and his interlocutors. In doing so, I will highlight the epistemic importance of recognizing disagreements. It is shown that there is a positive relationship between the correct method of philosophical argument and epistemic modesty, which plays a crucial role in solving disagreements and facilitating epistemic improvement. modesty, disagreement
引用
收藏
页码:24 / 44
页数:21
相关论文
共 50 条
[21]   Broad and narrow epistemic standing: its relevance to the epistemology of disagreement [J].
Robert Gressis .
Synthese, 2021, 198 :8289-8306
[22]   PLATO'S ARGUMENT FROM ENANTIA: PHAEDO, 69E6-72E1 [J].
Adams, Don .
EIRENE-STUDIA GRAECA ET LATINA, 2019, 55 :119-145
[23]   Harmony as a Model for the Human Soul? Simmias' Objections as Contributions to Plato's Hylomorphic Concept of the Soul in the Phaedo [J].
Melichar, Hannes Gustav .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF THE PLATONIC TRADITION, 2025, 19 (01) :1-24
[24]   THE EPISTEMIC COMPETENCE OF PLATO'S PHILOSOPHER-RULERS IN THE REPUBLIC [J].
Peprah, Stephen Oppong .
EIRENE-STUDIA GRAECA ET LATINA, 2021, 57 :119-147
[25]   SOCRATIC DIALOGUES ON A COMPLEX BODY-SOUL RELATION IN PLATO'S PHAEDO AND OLGA TOKARCZUK'S FLIGHTS [J].
Bendrat, Anna .
452 F-REVISTA DE TEORIA DE LA LITERATURA Y LITERATURA COMPARADA, 2020, (23) :191-211
[26]   "Do Not Weep for Me, but Weep for Yourselves": Luke 23,27-31 and Plato's Phaedo 117c [J].
Kozlowski, Jan M. .
ZEITSCHRIFT FUR DIE NEUTESTAMENTLICHE WISSENSCHAFT UND DIE KUNDE DER ALTEREN KIRCHE, 2024, 115 (02) :265-270
[27]   SOCRATES' "SWAN SONG" IN PLATO'S PHAEDO. SOCRATES' "SECRET DOCTRINE" ABOUT DEATH AND ETERNITY [J].
Pawlowski, Kazimierz .
SCHOLE-FILOSOFSKOE ANTIKOVEDENIE I KLASSICHESKAYA TRADITSIYA-SCHOLE-ANCIENT PHILOSOPHY AND THE CLASSICAL TRADITION, 2021, 15 (02) :595-610
[28]   Second Sailing towards Immortality and God On Plato's Phaedo 99e4-100a3, with an Outlook on Descartes' Meditations, AT VII, 67 [J].
Ferber, Rafael .
MNEMOSYNE, 2021, 74 (03) :371-400
[29]   THE DEMIURGE AND HIS ROLE IN PLATO'S TIMAEUS [J].
Stransky, Jiri .
LISTY FILOLOGICKE, 2018, 141 (3-4) :293-324
[30]   PLATO'S THEORY OF NUMBERS-PRINCIPLES AND ITS IMPORTANCE TO THE PHILOSOPHICAL RECONSTRUCTION OF PLATO'S DIALECTICS [J].
Mie, Fabian .
ARCHAI-REVISTA DE ESTUDOS SOBRE AS ORIGENS DO PENSAMENTO OCIDENTAL, 2011, 6 :99-108