Critical realism as a fractal philosophy

被引:0
作者
Isaksen, K. Robert [1 ]
机构
[1] UiT Arctic Univ Norway, Ctr Teaching Learning & Technol, Hansine Hansens Veg 18, N-9019 Tromso, Norway
关键词
Critical realism; meta-philosophy; epistemology;
D O I
10.1080/14767430.2024.2358465
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
There are two overarching questions that guide this paper: What are some potential issues with the criterion for judgemental rationality as developed by Bhaskar? How can critical realism itself be justified without foundationalist assumptions or an infinite regress of justification? The paper considers how Bhaskar's criterion for theory choice - developed in the natural sciences - can also be applied in the social sciences, how a criterion developed within epistemic relativity can be applied to overcome judgemental relativity, and explores justification of critical realism and of research inspired by this philosophy of science. It will be argued that a fractal form of justification can be an important approach to justify critical realist philosophy and its meta-philosophy (or 'the philosophy of philosophy'). I also seek to demonstrate that such fractal justification, and insights from other fractally coherent philosophies, can be helpful to provide answers to several of the issues with Bhaskar's criterion for judgemental rationality that are presented.
引用
收藏
页码:565 / 587
页数:23
相关论文
共 50 条
[21]   Critical realism and the dialectic [J].
Roberts, JM .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF SOCIOLOGY, 2001, 52 (04) :667-685
[22]   On the Origins of Critical Realism [J].
Losch, Andreas .
THEOLOGY AND SCIENCE, 2009, 7 (01) :85-106
[23]   Understanding Causation in Healthcare: An Introduction to Critical Realism [J].
Koopmans, Erica ;
Schiller, Catharine .
QUALITATIVE HEALTH RESEARCH, 2022, 32 (8-9) :1207-1214
[24]   Has Jonathan Bernier Rescued Critical Realism? [J].
Porter, Stanley E. ;
Pitts, Andrew W. .
JOURNAL FOR THE STUDY OF THE HISTORICAL JESUS, 2016, 14 (03) :241-247
[25]   CRITICAL REALISM AND THE SELF [J].
O'Mahoney, Joe .
JOURNAL OF CRITICAL REALISM, 2011, 10 (01) :122-129
[26]   SPECULATIVE AND CRITICAL REALISM [J].
Assiter, Alison .
JOURNAL OF CRITICAL REALISM, 2013, 12 (03) :283-300
[27]   Subjugating Subjectivity: Why Wright's Critical Realism is Not Critical Enough [J].
Chidgzey, Aaron .
JOURNAL FOR THE STUDY OF THE HISTORICAL JESUS, 2023, 21 (03) :203-227
[28]   LUKACS' CRITICAL ONTOLOGY AND CRITICAL REALISM [J].
Duayer, Mario ;
Medeiros, Joao Leonardo .
JOURNAL OF CRITICAL REALISM, 2005, 4 (02) :395-425
[29]   The contributions of scientific realism and critical realism to realist evaluation [J].
Mukumbang, Ferdinand C. ;
De Souza, Denise E. ;
Eastwood, John G. .
JOURNAL OF CRITICAL REALISM, 2023, 22 (03) :504-524
[30]   The Theological Hijacking of Realism Critical Realism in 'Science and Religion' [J].
Gironi, Fabio .
JOURNAL OF CRITICAL REALISM, 2012, 11 (01) :40-75