The efficacy of acupuncture therapies in cervical spondylotic radiculopathy: A network meta-analysis

被引:1
作者
Lin, Yingtong [1 ]
Zhong, Sha [2 ,3 ]
Huang, Chaoyuan [4 ]
Zhang, Gangyu [5 ]
Jiang, Ganghui [6 ]
机构
[1] Guangzhou Univ Chinese Med, Clin Med Coll Acupuncture Moxibust & Rehabil, Guangzhou, Peoples R China
[2] Guangzhou Univ Chinese Med, Clin Med Sch 1, Guangzhou, Peoples R China
[3] Guangzhou Women & Childrens Med Ctr, Dept Breast & Thyroid Surg, Guangzhou, Peoples R China
[4] Guangzhou Univ Chinese Med, Affiliated Hosp 2, Dept Gastroenterol, Guangzhou, Peoples R China
[5] Univ Basel, Dept Biomed Engn, Basel, Switzerland
[6] Guangzhou Univ Chinese Med, Affiliated Hosp 1, Acupuncture Moxibust & Rehabil Ctr, Guangzhou, Peoples R China
关键词
Acupuncture; Cervical spondylotic Radiculopathy; Network meta-analysis; MYELOPATHY; PAIN; MANAGEMENT;
D O I
10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e31793
中图分类号
O [数理科学和化学]; P [天文学、地球科学]; Q [生物科学]; N [自然科学总论];
学科分类号
07 ; 0710 ; 09 ;
摘要
Objective: To evaluate the efficacy of acupuncture-related therapy in the Bayesian setting by means of a network Meta-analysis. Methods: Relevant clinical randomized controlled trials(RCTs) of acupuncture-related therapy for Cervical Spondylotic Radiculopathy(CSR) were searched in the Chinese and English databases from the inception to November 13, 2023. Two researchers reviewed the literature, extracted the data, assessed the risk of bias of the included studies independently, and then used Stata14.0 and WinBUGs14 to analyze. Results: There are 28 RCTs in total, of which 2593 patients and 14 acupuncture interventions. Network Meta-analysis revealed that, regarding the VAS scores, Acupoint catgut-embedding, Fu's Subcutaneous Needling and Needle Knife are better than Conventional acupuncture, Electroacupuncture, Sham needle, Western Medicine, and Electrotherapy; Conventional acupuncture is better than Electrotherapy and Sham needle; Qihuang needle is superior to Sham needle and Electrotherapy; besides, Acupoint catgut-embedding is better than Tuina (Message), Chinese Medicine, Warm needle as well. Regarding the NDI scores, Needle Knife, Warm needle, Fire needle, Long round needle, Acupoint catgut-embedding are better than Conventional acupuncture, Electro-acupuncture, and Cervical traction; Conventional acupuncture is superior to Electroacupuncture, Cervical traction, Needle Knife and Warm needle; whereas we found Qihuang needle is superior to Acupoint catgut-embedding, besides, Need Knife is superior to Qihuang needle, Long round needle and Acupoint catgut-embedding. In terms of improving the Tanaka Yasuhiro 20-point scale scores(TY), Needle Knife and Qihuang needle are superior to Conventional acupuncture, Warm needle and Electro-acupuncture; moreover, Conventional acupuncture is better than Warm needle. Conclusion: In general, Acupoint catgut-embedding shows the best effect at relieving neck pain, then followed by Fu 's Subcutaneous Needling and Needle Knife. Needle Knife is the best intervention in improving the functionality of the cervical spine. Like improving overall clinical performance, Needle Knife is the best treatment. Furthermore, our conclusion still needs to confirmed by higher-quality documentation. In order to choose the best treatment for patients, clinicians are expected to take into account different clinical features and practical clinical tings with caution while choosing an acupuncture-related therapy in CSR. Key Message: This article aims at selecting the best acupuncture-related treatment for clinicians help patients in CSR, and the results of this study indicated that Acupoint catgut-embedding shows the best effect in relieving neck pain, Needle Knife shows the best effect in improving the functionality of cervical spine, Needle Knife shows the best effect in treating overall clinical performance.
引用
收藏
页数:22
相关论文
共 64 条
  • [1] An evidence-based clinical guideline for the diagnosis and treatment of cervical radiculopathy from degenerative disorders
    Bono, Christopher M.
    Ghiselli, Gary
    Gilbert, Thomas J.
    Kreiner, D. Scott
    Reitman, Charles
    Summers, Jeffrey T.
    Baisden, Jamie L.
    Easa, John
    Fernand, Robert
    Lamer, Tim
    Matz, Paul G.
    Mazanec, Daniel J.
    Resnick, Daniel K.
    Shaffer, William O.
    Sharma, Anil K.
    Timmons, Reuben B.
    Toton, John F.
    [J]. SPINE JOURNAL, 2011, 11 (01) : 64 - 72
  • [3] Chen C., 2016, Chin Arch Tradit Chin Med, V34, P934
  • [4] Childress MA, 2016, AM FAM PHYSICIAN, V93, P746
  • [5] Chinese Medical Association, 2010, Chinese Journal of Rheumatology, V14, P416, DOI [10.3760/cma.j.issn.1007-7480.2010.06.024, DOI 10.3760/CMA.J.ISSN.1007-7480.2010.06.024]
  • [6] Acupuncture for analgesia in the emergency department: a multicentre, randomised, equivalence and non-inferiority trial
    Cohen, Marc M.
    Smit, De Villiers
    Andrianopoulos, Nick
    Ben-Meir, Michael
    Taylor, David Mcd
    Parker, Shefton J.
    Xue, Chalie C.
    Cameron, Peter A.
    [J]. MEDICAL JOURNAL OF AUSTRALIA, 2017, 206 (11) : 494 - 499
  • [7] Treatment of a Patient with Cervical Radiculopathy Using Thoracic Spine Thrust Manipulation, Soft Tissue Mobilization, and Exercise
    Costello, Michael
    [J]. JOURNAL OF MANUAL & MANIPULATIVE THERAPY, 2008, 16 (03) : 129 - 135
  • [8] Di Zhong, 2014, Zhongguo Zhen Jiu, V34, P325
  • [9] Ding M., 2012, Shanghai J Acu-mox, V31, P900
  • [10] Fan D., 2012, Liaoning Journal of Chinese Medicine, V39, P1839