Performance evaluation of an automatic resonant switched capacitor-based voltage balancing circuits for series connected batteries

Electrical energy storage (EES) plays a crucial role in various power applications. Voltage imbalance is a common issue that can negatively affect the efficiency, reliability, and safety of EESs. Several types of voltage balancing (VB) circuits have been proposed in much of the literature. Among these VB circuits, switched capacitor (SC)-based circuits have attracted significant interest due to their efficiency, cost-effectiveness, compact size, and ease of control, but their balancing performance is not yet satisfactory. As a result, structural modifications in SC-based circuits have been widely proposed to improve balancing performance. However, not all of these circuit structures have been implemented into a resonant switched capacitor (RSC)-based voltage balancing, which has higher efficiency. Hence, this study aims to assess the efficiency of RSC-based VB circuits by conducting analog simulation using the Matlab Simulink software. This research evaluates the performance of the VB circuit not only in terms of its speed and efficiency, but also in terms of its energy distribution. The results show that the delta structure is the fastest in terms of balancing speed when completing the balancing process, followed by the mesh structure and the parallel structure. The best energy distribution is produced by a parallel structure, as indicated by the change in voltage of all battery cells always moving towards a convergent value, regardless of the variations in initial imbalance conditions. Meanwhile, other circuit structures distribute energy randomly, allowing the voltage of the battery cells to change not directly towards a convergent value. Lastly, the paper summarizes the balancing speed, efficiency, circuit complexity, and quality of energy distribution.