Masculinity and Violence Interconnectedness: Defining and Reconciling the Gender Paradox Among Men With Cumulative Lifetime Violence Histories

被引:2
作者
O'Donnell, Sue [1 ]
Taylor, Petrea [2 ]
Vincent, Charlene D. [1 ]
Scott-Storey, Kelly [1 ]
Wuest, Judith [1 ]
Malcolm, Jeannie [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ New Brunswick, Fac Nursing, POB 4400, Fredericton, NB E3B 5A3, Canada
[2] Univ New Brunswick, Fac Nursing, Moncton Campus, Moncton, NB, Canada
来源
SAGE OPEN | 2024年 / 14卷 / 03期
基金
加拿大健康研究院;
关键词
health; men; qualitative; gender; violence; masculinities; sex and gender; social sciences; INTERPERSONAL VIOLENCE; NORMS; PERCEPTIONS; EXPERIENCES; HARASSMENT; CONFORMITY; ABUSE; BOYS;
D O I
10.1177/21582440241266998
中图分类号
C [社会科学总论];
学科分类号
03 ; 0303 ;
摘要
Among men, gender and views about violence contribute to how men, and others, identify and respond to violence and related outcomes. Despite this, little is known about men's perspectives regarding gender/masculinities and cumulative lifetime violence (CLV) exposure. Using the qualitative method of Interpretative description, the complex relationship between gender and violence for men who have experienced CLV was explored. Interviews with thirty-two men who experienced CLV revealed a complex interrelation between masculinity and violence (MV interconnectedness). This intricate connection is difficult to separate due to persistent normalization and acceptance of violence. Because violence is one way that men live up to pressure to 'be a man,' MV interconnectedness positively contributes to men's sense of self. However, MV interconnectedness also contributes to significant harm. The contradictory nature of MV interconnectedness and the tension that arises when men contemplate the link between gender and violence was labelled 'the paradox'. As men grapple with the paradox, and the ways that gender and violence have influenced their lives, they are able to move toward disconnecting violence from how they define themselves as men. The paradox is a significant addition to the understanding of how men may reject the narrative that masculinity and violence are interconnected. MV Interconnectedness demonstrates that the link between masculinity and violence perpetration is not straightforward. Normalization and acceptance of violence calls for efforts to counteract the messages and pressures boys and men receive that influence their behaviour. Understanding masculinity and violence interconnectedness among men with cumulative lifetime violence historiesAmong men, gender and views about violence contribute to how men, and others, identify and respond to violence and related outcomes. Despite this, little is known about men's perspectives regarding gender/masculinities and cumulative lifetime violence (CLV) exposure. Using Interpretive Description analysis of qualitative interviews with men, we explored the complex relationship between gender and violence for men who have experienced CLV. This revealed a complex interrelationship between masculinity and violence (MV interconnectedness). This intricate connection is difficult to separate due to persistent normalization and acceptance of violence. Because violence is one way that men live up to pressure to "be a man," MV interconnectedness positively contributes to men's sense of self. However, MV interconnectedness also contributes to significant harm. The contradictory nature of MV interconnectedness and the tension that arises when men contemplate the link between gender and violence was labelled "the paradox." As men grapple with the paradox, and the ways that gender and violence have influenced their lives, they are able to move toward disconnecting violence from how they define themselves as men.
引用
收藏
页数:13
相关论文
共 58 条
  • [1] Adams E., 2020, Reinventing masculinity: The liberating power of compassion and connection
  • [2] Inclusive Masculinity Theory: overview, reflection and refinement
    Anderson, Eric
    McCormack, Mark
    [J]. JOURNAL OF GENDER STUDIES, 2018, 27 (05) : 547 - 561
  • [3] [Anonymous], 2018, APA guidelines for psychological practice with boys and men
  • [4] Berdahl JL, 2007, ACAD MANAGE REV, V32, P641, DOI 10.5465/AMR.2007.24351879
  • [5] Brazier J E., 2019, Value in Health
  • [6] "How Many Silences Are There?" Men's Experience of Victimization in Intimate Partner Relationships
    Brooks, Carolyn
    Martin, Stephanie
    Broda, Lisa
    Poudrier, Jennifer
    [J]. JOURNAL OF INTERPERSONAL VIOLENCE, 2020, 35 (23-24) : 5390 - 5413
  • [7] Burcar V., 2009, Journal of Scandinavian Studies in Criminology and Crime Prevention, V37, P37, DOI DOI 10.1080/14043850902815073
  • [8] Interpretive description: A flexible qualitative methodology for medical education research
    Burdine, Julie Thompson
    Thorne, Sally
    Sandhu, Gurjit
    [J]. MEDICAL EDUCATION, 2021, 55 (03) : 336 - 343
  • [9] Carlson M., 2009, The Journal of Men's Studies, V16, P3, DOI [https://doi.org/10.3149/jms.1601.3, DOI 10.3149/JMS.1601.3]
  • [10] How Preschoolers Associate Power with Gender in Male-Female Interactions: A Cross-Cultural Investigation
    Charafeddine, Rawan
    Zambrana, Imac Maria
    Triniol, Benoit
    Mercier, Hugo
    Clement, Fabrice
    Kaufmann, Laurence
    Reboul, Anne
    Pons, Francisco
    Van der Henst, Jean-Baptiste
    [J]. SEX ROLES, 2020, 83 (7-8) : 453 - 473