Questioning the Role of Carotid Artery Ultrasound in Assessing Fluid Responsiveness in Critical Illness: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

被引:1
作者
Walker, Samuel C. D. [1 ]
Lipszyc, Adam C. [2 ]
Kilmurray, Matthew [1 ]
Wilding, Helen [3 ]
Akhlaghi, Hamed [1 ,4 ]
机构
[1] St Vincents Hosp, Dept Emergency Med, Melbourne, Vic, Australia
[2] St Vincents Hosp, Dept Anaesthesia & Acute Pain Med, Melbourne, Vic, Australia
[3] St Vincents Hosp, Lib Serv, Melbourne, Vic, Australia
[4] Univ Melbourne, Dept Med Educ, Melbourne, Vic, Australia
关键词
VOLUME RESPONSIVENESS; CARDIAC-OUTPUT; SEPTIC SHOCK; BLOOD-FLOW; DOPPLER; SEPSIS; TIME; CARE; THERMODILUTION; BIOREACTANCE;
D O I
10.1155/2024/9102961
中图分类号
R4 [临床医学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100602 ;
摘要
Background. A noninvasive and accurate method of identifying fluid responsiveness in hemodynamically unstable patients has long been sought by physicians. Carotid ultrasound (US) is one such modality previously canvassed for this purpose. The aim of this novel systematic review and meta-analysis is to investigate whether critically unwell patients who are requiring intravenous (IV) fluid resuscitation (fluid responders) can be identified accurately with carotid US. Methods. The protocol was registered with PROSPERO on the 30/11/2022 (ID number: CRD42022380284). Studies investigating carotid ultrasound accuracy in assessing fluid responsiveness in hemodynamically unstable patients were included. Studies were identified through searches of six databases, all run on 4 November 2022, Medline, Embase, Emcare, APA PsycInfo, CINAHL, and Cochrane Library. Risk of bias was assessed using the QUADAS-2 and the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluations (GRADE) guidelines. Results were pooled, meta-analysis was conducted where amenable, and hierarchical summary receiver operating characteristic models were established to compare carotid ultrasound measures. Results. Seventeen studies were included (n = 842), with 1048 fluid challenges. 441 (42.1%) were fluid responsive. Four different carotid US measures were investigated, including change in carotid doppler peak velocity (triangle CDPV), carotid blood flow (CBF), change in carotid artery velocity time integral (triangle CAVTI), and carotid flow time (CFT). Pooled carotid US had a pooled sensitivity, specificity, and AUROC with 95% confidence intervals (CI) of 0.73 (0.66-0.78), 0.82 (0.72-0.90), and 0.81 (0.78-0.85), respectively. triangle CDPV had sensitivity, specificity, and AUROC with 95% CI of 0.72 (0.64-0.80), 0.87 (0.73-0.94), and 0.82 (0.78-0.85), respectively. CBF had sensitivity, specificity, and AUROC with 95% CI of 0.70 (0.56-0.80), 0.80 (0.50-0.94), and 0.77 (0.78-0.85), respectively. Risk of bias and assessment was undertaken using the QUADAS-2 and GRADE tools. The QUADAS-2 found that studies generally had an unclear or high risk of bias but with low applicability concerns. The GRADE assessment showed that triangle CDPV and CBF had low accuracy for sensitivity and specificity. Conclusion. It appears that carotid US has a limited ability to predict fluid responsiveness in critically unwell patients. triangle CDPV demonstrates the greatest accuracy of all measures analyzed. Further high-quality studies using consistent study design would help confirm this.
引用
收藏
页数:19
相关论文
共 49 条
  • [1] CHANGE IN CAROTID BLOOD FLOW AND CAROTID CORRECTED FLOW TIME ASSESSED BY NOVICE SONOLOGISTS FAILS TO DETERMINE FLUID RESPONSIVENESS IN SPONTANEOUSLY BREATHING INTENSIVE CARE UNIT PATIENTS
    Abbasi, Adeel
    Azab, Nader
    Nayeemuddin, Mohammed
    Schick, Alexandra
    Lopardo, Thomas
    Phillips, Gary S.
    Merchant, Roland C.
    Levy, Mitchell M.
    Blaivas, Michael
    Corl, Keith A.
    [J]. ULTRASOUND IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY, 2020, 46 (10) : 2659 - 2666
  • [2] Respiratory Variation in Carotid Artery Peak Systolic Velocity Is Unable to Predict Fluid Responsiveness in Spontaneously Breathing Critically Ill Patients When Assessed by Novice Physician Sonologists
    Abbasi, Adeel
    Nayeemuddin, Mohammed
    Azab, Nader
    Schick, Alexandra
    Lopardo, Thomas
    Phillips, Gary S.
    Merchant, Roland C.
    Levy, Mitchell M.
    Blaivas, Michael
    Corl, Keith A.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF INTENSIVE CARE MEDICINE, 2021, 36 (08) : 885 - 892
  • [3] Alhabashy WS., 2021, Anaesth Pain Intensive Care, V25, P722
  • [4] Ultrasound Assessment of the Change in Carotid Corrected Flow Time in Fluid Responsiveness in Undifferentiated Shock
    Barjaktarevic, Igor
    Toppen, William E.
    Hu, Scott
    Montoya, Elizabeth Aquije
    Ong, Stephanie
    Buhr, Russell
    David, Ian J.
    Wang, Tisha
    Rezayat, Talayeh
    Chang, Steven Y.
    Elashoff, David
    Markovic, Daniela
    Berlin, David
    Cannesson, Maxime
    [J]. CRITICAL CARE MEDICINE, 2018, 46 (11) : E1040 - E1046
  • [5] Carotid Ultrasound to Predict Fluid Responsiveness A Systematic Review
    Beier, Lance
    Davis, Joshua
    Esener, Dasia
    Grant, Charles
    Fields, J. Matthew
    [J]. JOURNAL OF ULTRASOUND IN MEDICINE, 2020, 39 (10) : 1965 - 1976
  • [6] Fluid responsiveness predicted by noninvasive Bioreactance-based passive leg raise test
    Benomar, Brahim
    Ouattara, Alexandre
    Estagnasie, Philippe
    Brusset, Alain
    Squara, Pierre
    [J]. INTENSIVE CARE MEDICINE, 2010, 36 (11) : 1875 - 1881
  • [7] Rationale for using the velocity-time integral and the minute distance for assessing the stroke volume and cardiac output in point-of-care settings
    Blanco, Pablo
    [J]. ULTRASOUND JOURNAL, 2020, 12 (01)
  • [8] Fluid resuscitation in human sepsis: Time to rewrite history?
    Byrne, Liam
    Van Haren, Frank
    [J]. ANNALS OF INTENSIVE CARE, 2017, 7
  • [9] Efficacy of Left Ventricular Outflow Tract and Carotid Artery Velocity Time Integral as Predictors of Fluid Responsiveness in Patients with Sepsis and Septic Shock
    Chowhan, Ganesh
    Kundu, Riddhi
    Maitra, Souvik
    Arora, Mahesh K.
    Batra, Ravinder K.
    Subramaniam, Rajeshwari
    Baidya, Dalim K.
    Trikha, Anjan
    [J]. INDIAN JOURNAL OF CRITICAL CARE MEDICINE, 2021, 25 (03) : 310 - 316
  • [10] Improving the translation of search strategies using the Polyglot Search Translator: a randomized controlled trial
    Clark, Justin Michael
    Sanders, Sharon
    Carter, Matthew
    Honeyman, David
    Cleo, Gina
    Auld, Yvonne
    Booth, Debbie
    Condron, Patrick
    Dalais, Christine
    Bateup, Sarah
    Linthwaite, Bronwyn
    May, Nikki
    Munn, Jo
    Ramsay, Lindy
    Rickett, Kirsty
    Rutter, Cameron
    Smith, Angela
    Sondergeld, Peter
    Wallin, Margie
    Jones, Mark
    Beller, Elaine
    [J]. JOURNAL OF THE MEDICAL LIBRARY ASSOCIATION, 2020, 108 (02) : 195 - 207