Meta-analysis of high-power short-duration versus cryoballoon ablation for atrial fibrillation

被引:2
作者
Lin, Limin [1 ,2 ]
Huang, Ying [3 ]
Huang, Qunying [4 ]
Yu, Fuling [4 ]
Mao, Yinjun [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] Fujian Med Univ, Affiliated Hosp 1, Dept Pharm, Fuzhou 350005, Peoples R China
[2] Fujian Med Univ, Affiliated Hosp 1, Natl Reg Med Ctr, Dept Pharm, Binhai Campus, Fuzhou 350212, Peoples R China
[3] Fujian Med Univ, Union Hosp, Dept Cardiovasc Surg Nursing, Fuzhou, Peoples R China
[4] Fujian Med Univ, Affiliated Hosp 1, Dept Cardiol, Fuzhou, Peoples R China
来源
PACE-PACING AND CLINICAL ELECTROPHYSIOLOGY | 2024年 / 47卷 / 08期
关键词
atrial fibrillation; cryoballoon ablation; high-power short-duration; meta-analysis; procedural efficiency; PULMONARY VEIN ISOLATION; CATHETER ABLATION; RADIOFREQUENCY; SAFETY;
D O I
10.1111/pace.15004
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
BackgroundThe existing literature regarding the treatment strategy for high-power short-duration (HPSD) ablation in patients diagnosed with atrial fibrillation (AF) is currently insufficient. The objective of this study is to perform a comparative analysis evaluating the effectiveness, safety, and procedural efficiency of HPSD versus cryoballoon ablation (CBA) for AF.MethodsA comprehensive search was conducted in PubMed, EMBASE, Cochrane Library, Scopus, Web of Science, and ClinicalTrials.gov databases to identify trials comparing HPSD with CBA for AF from their inception until December 25, 2023. Treatment effect measures were expressed as odds ratio (OR), mean difference (MD), accompanied by a 95% confidence interval (CI).ResultsThe analysis comprised six eligible trials involving a total enrollment of 2481 patients. No statistically significant disparities were observed in recurrent atrial arrhythmia (OR 0.90; 95% CI, 0.71-1.16) or total complications (OR 0.65; 95% CI, 0.38-1.12) between the two ablation techniques examined in this study. However, HPSD technique exhibited a significantly prolonged procedure time (MD 27.42; 95% CI, 19.03 to 35.81). Conversely, no significant differences were observed between the two modalities in terms of total fluoroscopy duration (MD -4.37; 95% CI -10.70 to 1.96) and ablation time (MD 7.95; 95% CI -3.97 to 19.88). Furthermore, HPSD demonstrated significantly higher odds of extrapulmonary vein (PV) trigger ablation compared to CBA (OR 18.86; 95% CI, 5.12-69.49). The subgroup analyses revealed that CBA continued to exhibit superior procedure time (except for the paroxysmal AF subgroup: [MD 29.52; 95% CI -4.25 to 63.60]), while no significant differences in safety and efficacy (except for the HPSD >= 70 W subgroup: [OR 0.44, 95% CI 0.20-0.97]) outcomes were still observed.ConclusionAmong patients undergoing ablation therapy for AF, both HPSD and CBA demonstrate comparable efficacy and safety profiles; however, HPSD is associated with longer procedural time and higher rates of extra-PV trigger ablation.
引用
收藏
页码:1013 / 1024
页数:12
相关论文
共 30 条
[1]   High-power short-duration versus standard radiofrequency ablation: Insights on lesion metrics [J].
Bourier, Felix ;
Duchateau, Josselin ;
Vlachos, Konstantinos ;
Lam, Anna ;
Martin, Claire A. ;
Takigawa, Masateru ;
Kitamura, Takeshi ;
Frontera, Antonio ;
Cheniti, Ghassen ;
Pambrun, Thomas ;
Klotz, Nicolas ;
Denis, Arnaud ;
Derval, Nicolas ;
Cochet, Hubert ;
Sacher, Frederic ;
Hocini, Meleze ;
Haissaguerre, Michel ;
Jais, Pierre .
JOURNAL OF CARDIOVASCULAR ELECTROPHYSIOLOGY, 2018, 29 (11) :1570-1575
[2]   Multicenter prospective comparison of conventional and high-power short duration radiofrequency application for pulmonary vein isolation: the high-power short-duration radiofrequency application for faster and safer pulmonary vein ablation (POWER FAST III) trial [J].
Castrejon-Castrejon, Sergio ;
Cossiani, Marcel Martinez ;
Jauregui-Abularach, Miguel ;
Sola, Nuria Basterra ;
Criado, Jose Luis Ibanez ;
Asensi, Joaquin Osca ;
Luque, Ivo Roca ;
Mitjans, Angel Moya ;
Dorador, Aurelio Quesada ;
Olivares, Victor Manuel Hidalgo ;
Castellano, Nicasio Perez ;
Gomez, Juan Manuel Fernandez ;
Macias-Ruiz, Maria Rosa ;
Villanueva, Bruno Bochard ;
Bada, Nerea Gonzalo ;
Prieto, Andres Fernandez ;
Lopez, Leonardo Elias Guido ;
Maldonado, Maria Eugenia Martinez ;
Merino, Daniel ;
Cervantes, Carlos Escobar ;
Merino, Jose Luis ;
OWER FAST III trial invest .
JOURNAL OF INTERVENTIONAL CARDIAC ELECTROPHYSIOLOGY, 2023, 66 (08) :1889-1899
[3]   Patient experience of very high power short duration radiofrequency ablation for atrial fibrillation under mild conscious sedation [J].
Chu, Gavin ;
Calvert, Peter ;
Sidhu, Bharat ;
Mavilakandy, Akash ;
Kotb, Ahmed ;
Tovmassian, Lilith ;
Kozhuharov, Nikola ;
Bierme, Cedric ;
Denham, Nathan ;
Pius, Charlene ;
O'Brien, Jim ;
Ding, Wern Yew ;
Luther, Vishal ;
Snowdon, Richard L. ;
Ng, G. Andre ;
Gupta, Dhiraj .
JOURNAL OF INTERVENTIONAL CARDIAC ELECTROPHYSIOLOGY, 2023, 66 (02) :445-453
[4]   Diaphragmatic electromyography during cryoballoon ablation: a novel concept in the prevention of phrenic nerve palsy [J].
Franceschi, Frederic ;
Dubuc, Marc ;
Guerra, Peter G. ;
Delisle, Stephane ;
Romeo, Philippe ;
Landry, Evelyn ;
Koutbi, Linda ;
Rivard, Lena ;
Macle, Laurent ;
Thibault, Bernard ;
Talajic, Mario ;
Roy, Denis ;
Khairy, Paul .
HEART RHYTHM, 2011, 8 (06) :885-891
[5]   Phrenic Nerve Injury During Cryoballoon-Based Pulmonary Vein Isolation: Results of the Worldwide YETI Registry [J].
Heeger, Christian-H ;
Sohns, Christian ;
Pott, Alexander ;
Metzner, Andreas ;
Inaba, Osamu ;
Straube, Florian ;
Kuniss, Malte ;
Aryana, Arash ;
Miyazaki, Shinsuke ;
Cay, Serkan ;
Ehrlich, Joachim R. ;
El-Battrawy, Ibrahim ;
Martinek, Martin ;
Saguner, Ardan M. ;
Tscholl, Verena ;
Yalin, Kivanc ;
Lyan, Evgeny ;
Su, Wilber ;
Papiashvili, Giorgi ;
Botros, Maichel Sobhy Naguib ;
Gasperetti, Alessio ;
Proietti, Riccardo ;
Wissner, Erik ;
Scherr, Daniel ;
Kamioka, Masashi ;
Makimoto, Hisaki ;
Urushida, Tsuyoshi ;
Aksu, Tolga ;
Chun, Julian K. R. ;
Aytemir, Kudret ;
Jedrzejczyk-Patej, Ewa ;
Kuck, Karl-Heinz ;
Dahme, Tillman ;
Steven, Daniel ;
Sommer, Philipp ;
Tilz, Roland Richard .
CIRCULATION-ARRHYTHMIA AND ELECTROPHYSIOLOGY, 2022, 15 (01) :23-32
[6]   Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta-analysis [J].
Higgins, JPT ;
Thompson, SG .
STATISTICS IN MEDICINE, 2002, 21 (11) :1539-1558
[7]  
Jain Ankit, 2023, Indian Pacing Electrophysiol J, V23, P110, DOI 10.1016/j.ipej.2023.04.001
[8]   Evaluation of Isolation Area, Myocardial Injury and Left Atrial Function Following High-Power Short-Duration Radiofrequency or Second-Generation Cryoballoon Ablation for Atrial Fibrillation [J].
Kassa, Krisztian Istvan ;
Nagy, Zsofia ;
Simkovits, Daniel ;
Kis, Zsuzsanna ;
Ferenci, Tamas ;
Som, Zoltan ;
Foldesi, Csaba ;
Kardos, Attila .
JOURNAL OF CARDIOVASCULAR DEVELOPMENT AND DISEASE, 2022, 9 (10)
[9]   10-year nationwide trends of the incidence, prevalence, and adverse outcomes of non-valvular atrial fibrillation nationwide health insurance data covering the entire Korean population [J].
Kim, Daehoon ;
Yang, Pil-Sung ;
Jang, Eunsun ;
Yu, Hee Tae ;
Kim, Tae-Hoon ;
Uhm, Jae-Sun ;
Kim, Jong-Youn ;
Pak, Hui-Nam ;
Lee, Moon-Hyoung ;
Joung, Boyoung ;
Lip, Gregory Y. H. .
AMERICAN HEART JOURNAL, 2018, 202 :20-26
[10]   Atrial fibrillation and the risk of ischaemic strokes or intracranial haemorrhages: comparisons of the catheter ablation, medical therapy, and non-atrial fibrillation population [J].
Kim, Min ;
Yu, Hee Tae ;
Kim, JongYoun ;
Kim, Tae-Hoon ;
Uhm, Jae-Sun ;
Joung, Boyoung ;
Lee, Moon-Hyoung ;
Pak, Hui-Nam .
EUROPACE, 2021, 23 (04) :529-538