Every Wholly Other: Postsecular Pluralism in Isabel Rocamora's Faith

In this article, I undertake a close reading of Isabel Rocamora's 2015 film installation Faith, which shows, on three separate screens, Jewish, Christian, and Muslim men simultaneously performing their morning prayers in three distinct, historically significant sites in the Judean desert. Setting the cinematic and installation properties of the work into dialogue with a number of philosophers (Levinas, Derrida, Cavell), film theorists (Bazin, Deleuze, Chion), and art theorists (Fried, Elkins), I argue that it adopts a postsecular approach to religious pluralism. That is, without being a religious artwork, Faith nevertheless deconstructs the conventional liberal secular approach of universalist neutrality towards interreligious relations and instead configures the relations between the human figures in the work according to an alterity that requires not cognitive certainty but interhuman faith. The work is thereby consistent with Derrida's notion that tout autre est tout autre (every other is wholly other).