Analysis of some of the statements of L. Holmlid about T plus D fusion, D plus D fusion and ultra-dense hydrogen

被引:0
作者
Shmatov, Mikhail L. [1 ]
机构
[1] Ioffe Inst, St Petersburg 194021, Russia
关键词
Thermonuclear fusion; Inertial fusion energy; Breeding of tritium; Ultra-dense hydrogen; Antiproton; ENERGY;
D O I
10.1186/s13705-024-00470-3
中图分类号
X [环境科学、安全科学];
学科分类号
08 ; 0830 ;
摘要
Background Thermonuclear fusion is a widely discussed approach to energy production. In 2022, Energy Sustain. Soc. published L. Holmlid's paper (Energy Sustain Soc 12:14, 2022, 10.1186/s13705-022-00338-4) containing, in particular, critical statements about the plans for use of the T + D fusion in energy production. An analysis of these and several other statements of L. Holmlid is presented. This analysis complements a similar analysis performed by K. Hansen and J. Engelen (Energy Sustain Soc 13:14, 2023, 10.1186/s13705-023-00403-6). Main text It is shown that several statements of L. Holmlid about D + T fusion and D + D fusion are mistaken or ungrounded. It is also shown that the statement of L. Holmlid about the products of annihilation of low-energy antiprotons with protons in ultra-dense hydrogen differs strongly from the data on the products of annihilation of stopped antiprotons with protons in liquid hydrogen and with nucleons of the nuclei of elements heavier than hydrogen. Conclusion The statement "The use of all resources for fusion research on non-sustainable D + T fusion instead of sustainable muon-induced fusion may be a fatal mistake for humanity", made by L. Holmlid in his Reply (Energy Sustain Soc 13:25, 2023, 10.1186/s13705-023-00404-5) to the aforementioned paper by K. Hansen and J. Engelen, is mistaken.
引用
收藏
页数:4
相关论文
共 28 条
[1]   Burn performance of fast ignited, tritium-poor ICF fuels [J].
Atzeni, S ;
Ciampi, ML .
NUCLEAR FUSION, 1997, 37 (12) :1665-1677
[2]  
Atzeni S., 2004, International Series of Monographs on Physics, DOI [10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198562641.001.0001, DOI 10.1093/ACPROF:OSO/9780198562641.001.0001]
[3]   Future for inertial-fusion energy in Europe: a roadmap [J].
Batani, Dimitri ;
Colaitis, Arnaud ;
Consoli, Fabrizio ;
Danson, Colin N. ;
Gizzi, Leonida Antonio ;
Honrubia, Javier ;
Kuehl, Thomas ;
Le Pape, Sebastien ;
Miquel, Jean-Luc ;
Perlado, Jose Manuel ;
Scott, R. H. H. ;
Tatarakis, Michael ;
Tikhonchuk, Vladimir ;
Volpe, Luca .
HIGH POWER LASER SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING, 2023, 11
[4]   High-gain direct-drive target design for laser fusion [J].
Bodner, SE ;
Colombant, DG ;
Schmitt, AJ ;
Klapisch, M .
PHYSICS OF PLASMAS, 2000, 7 (06) :2298-2301
[5]  
Duderstadt J. J., 1982, Inertial Confinement Fusion
[6]  
Feoktistov L. P., 1998, PHYS-USP, V41, P1139, DOI DOI 10.1070/PU1998v041n11ABEH000506
[7]   Thermonuclear detonation [J].
Feoktistov, LP .
USPEKHI FIZICHESKIKH NAUK, 1998, 168 (11) :1247-1255
[8]  
Feoktistov LP, 1998, From the past to the future: from the hopes on bomb to reliable reactor
[9]   Are claims of cheap muon production correct? [J].
Hansen, Klavs ;
Engelen, Jos .
ENERGY SUSTAINABILITY AND SOCIETY, 2023, 13 (01)
[10]   Response to the comment "Are claims of cheap muon production correct?" by K. Hansen and J. Engelen, Energy Sustain. Soc., 2023 [J].
Holmlid, L. .
ENERGY SUSTAINABILITY AND SOCIETY, 2023, 13 (01)