Review of Hubble tension solutions with new SH0ES and SPT-3G data

被引:36
作者
Khalife, Ali Rida [1 ]
Zanjani, Maryam Bahrami [2 ]
Galli, Silvia [1 ]
Gunther, Sven [2 ]
Lesgourgues, Julien [2 ]
Benabed, Karim [1 ]
机构
[1] Sorbonne Univ, Inst Astrophys Paris, CNRS, UMR 7095, 98 Bis Bd Arago, F-75014 Paris, France
[2] Rhein Westfal TH Aachen, Inst Theoret Particle Phys & Cosmol TTK, Sommerfeldstr 16, D-52056 Aachen, Germany
基金
欧洲研究理事会;
关键词
cosmological parameters from CMBR; cosmological parameters from LSS; cosmology of theories beyond the SM; physics of the early universe; MASSIVE NEUTRINOS; CONSTRAINTS; PLANCK;
D O I
10.1088/1475-7516/2024/04/059
中图分类号
P1 [天文学];
学科分类号
0704 ;
摘要
We present an updated analysis of eleven cosmological models that may help reduce the Hubble tension, which now reaches the 6 sigma level when considering the latest SH0ES measurement versus recent CMB and BAO data, assuming Lambda CDM. Specifically, we look at five classical extensions of Lambda CDM (with massive neutrinos, spatial curvature, free -streaming or self -interacting relativistic relics, or dynamical dark energy) and six elaborate models featuring either a time -varying electron mass, early dark energy or some non -trivial interactions in the neutrino sector triggered by a light Majoron. We improve over previous works in several ways. We include the latest data from the South Pole Telescope as well as the most recent measurement of the Hubble rate by the SH0ES collaboration. We treat the summed neutrino mass as a free parameter in most of our models, which reveals interesting degeneracies and constraints. We define additional metrics to assess the potential of a model to reduce or even solve the Hubble tension. We validate an emulator that uses active learning to train itself during each parameter inference run for any arbitrary model. We find that the time -varying electron mass and the Majoron models are now ruled out at more than 3 sigma. Models with a time -varying electron mass and spatial curvature or with early dark energy reduce the tension to 1.0-2.9 sigma. Nevertheless, none of the models considered in this work is favored with enough statistical significance to become the next concordance model of Cosmology.
引用
收藏
页数:54
相关论文
共 148 条
[1]  
Abbott BP, 2021, ASTROPHYS J, V909, DOI 10.3847/1538-4357/abdcb7
[2]   Cosmology intertwined: A review of the particle physics, astrophysics, and cosmology associated with the cosmological tensions and anomalies [J].
Abdalla, Elcio ;
Abellan, Guillermo Franco ;
Aboubrahim, Amin ;
Agnello, Adriano ;
Akarsu, Ozgur ;
Akrami, Yashar ;
Alestas, George ;
Aloni, Daniel ;
Amendola, Luca ;
Anchordoqui, Luis A. ;
Anderson, Richard I. ;
Arendse, Nikki ;
Asgari, Marika ;
Ballardini, Mario ;
Bargerx, Vernon ;
Basilakos, Spyros ;
Batista, Ronaldo C. ;
Battistelli, Elia S. ;
Battye, Richard ;
Benetti, Micol ;
Benisty, David ;
Berlin, Asher ;
de Bernardis, Paolo ;
Berti, Emanuele ;
Bidenko, Bohdan ;
Birrer, Simon ;
Blakeslee, John P. ;
Boddy, Kimberly K. ;
Bom, Clecio R. ;
Bonilla, Alexander ;
Borghi, Nicola ;
Bouchet, Francois R. ;
Braglia, Matteo ;
Buchert, Thomas ;
Buckley-Geer, Elizabeth ;
Calabrese, Erminia ;
Caldwell, Robert R. ;
Camarena, David ;
Capozziello, Salvatore ;
Casertano, Stefano ;
Chen, Angela ;
Chen, Geoff C-F ;
Chen, Hsin-Yu ;
Chluba, Jens ;
Chudaykin, Anton ;
Cicoli, Michele ;
Copi, Craig J. ;
Courbin, Fred ;
Cyr-Racine, Francis-Yan ;
Czerny, Bozena .
JOURNAL OF HIGH ENERGY ASTROPHYSICS, 2022, 34 :49-211
[3]   Probing early modification of gravity with Planck, ACT and SPT [J].
Abellan, Guillermo Franco ;
Braglia, Matteo ;
Ballardini, Mario ;
Finelli, Fabio ;
Poulin, Vivian .
JOURNAL OF COSMOLOGY AND ASTROPARTICLE PHYSICS, 2023, (12)
[4]   Planck intermediate results XXIV. Constraints on variations in fundamental constants [J].
Ade, P. A. R. ;
Aghanim, N. ;
Arnaud, M. ;
Ashdown, M. ;
Aumont, J. ;
Baccigalupi, C. ;
Banday, A. J. ;
Barreiro, R. B. ;
Battaner, E. ;
Benabed, K. ;
Benoit-Levy, A. ;
Bernard, J. -P. ;
Bersanelli, M. ;
Bielewicz, P. ;
Bond, J. R. ;
Borrill, J. ;
Bouchet, F. R. ;
Burigana, C. ;
Butler, R. C. ;
Calabrese, E. ;
Chamballu, A. ;
Chiang, H. C. ;
Christensen, P. R. ;
Clements, D. L. ;
Colombo, L. P. L. ;
Couchot, F. ;
Curto, A. ;
Cuttaia, F. ;
Danese, L. ;
Davies, R. D. ;
Davis, R. J. ;
de Bernardis, P. ;
de Rosa, A. ;
de Zotti, G. ;
Delabrouille, J. ;
Diego, J. M. ;
Dole, H. ;
Dore, O. ;
Dupac, X. ;
Ensslin, T. A. ;
Eriksen, H. K. ;
Fabre, O. ;
Finelli, F. ;
Forni, O. ;
Frailis, M. ;
Franceschi, E. ;
Galeotta, S. ;
Galli, S. ;
Ganga, K. ;
Giard, M. .
ASTRONOMY & ASTROPHYSICS, 2015, 580
[5]   Planck 2013 results. XVI. Cosmological parameters [J].
Ade, P. A. R. ;
Aghanim, N. ;
Armitage-Caplan, C. ;
Arnaud, M. ;
Ashdown, M. ;
Atrio-Barandela, F. ;
Aumont, J. ;
Baccigalupi, C. ;
Banday, A. J. ;
Barreiro, R. B. ;
Bartlett, J. G. ;
Battaner, E. ;
Benabed, K. ;
Benoit, A. ;
Benoit-Levy, A. ;
Bernard, J. -P. ;
Bersanelli, M. ;
Bielewicz, P. ;
Bobin, J. ;
Bock, J. J. ;
Bonaldi, A. ;
Bond, J. R. ;
Borrill, J. ;
Bouchet, F. R. ;
Bridges, M. ;
Bucher, M. ;
Burigana, C. ;
Butler, R. C. ;
Calabrese, E. ;
Cappellini, B. ;
Cardoso, J. -F. ;
Catalano, A. ;
Challinor, A. ;
Chamballu, A. ;
Chary, R. -R. ;
Chen, X. ;
Chiang, H. C. ;
Chiang, L. -Y ;
Christensen, P. R. ;
Church, S. ;
Clements, D. L. ;
Colombi, S. ;
Colombo, L. P. L. ;
Couchot, F. ;
Coulais, A. ;
Crill, B. P. ;
Curto, A. ;
Cuttaia, F. ;
Danese, L. ;
Davies, R. D. .
ASTRONOMY & ASTROPHYSICS, 2014, 571
[6]   Planck 2018 results: I. Overview and the cosmological legacy of Planck [J].
Aghanim, N. ;
Akrami, Y. ;
Arroja, F. ;
Ashdown, M. ;
Aumont, J. ;
Baccigalupi, C. ;
Ballardini, M. ;
Banday, A. J. ;
Barreiro, R. B. ;
Bartolo, N. ;
Basak, S. ;
Battye, R. ;
Benabed, K. ;
Bernard, J. -P. ;
Bersanelli, M. ;
Bielewicz, P. ;
Bock, J. J. ;
Bond, J. R. ;
Borrill, J. ;
Bouchet, F. R. ;
Boulanger, F. ;
Bucher, M. ;
Burigana, C. ;
Butler, R. C. ;
Calabrese, E. ;
Cardoso, J. -F. ;
Carron, J. ;
Casaponsa, B. ;
Challinor, A. ;
Chiang, H. C. ;
Colombo, L. P. L. ;
Combet, C. ;
Contreras, D. ;
Crill, B. P. ;
Cuttaia, F. ;
de Bernardis, P. ;
de Zotti, G. ;
Delabrouille, J. ;
Delouis, J. -M. ;
Desert, F. -X. ;
Di Valentino, E. ;
Dickinson, C. ;
Diego, J. M. ;
Donzelli, S. ;
Dore, O. ;
Douspis, M. ;
Ducout, A. ;
Dupac, X. ;
Efstathiou, G. ;
Elsner, F. .
ASTRONOMY & ASTROPHYSICS, 2020, 641
[7]   Planck 2018 results: V. CMB power spectra and likelihoods [J].
Aghanim, N. ;
Akrami, Y. ;
Ashdown, M. ;
Aumont, J. ;
Baccigalupi, C. ;
Ballardini, M. ;
Banday, A. J. ;
Barreiro, R. B. ;
Bartolo, N. ;
Basak, S. ;
Benabed, K. ;
Bernard, J. -P. ;
Bersanelli, M. ;
Bielewicz, P. ;
Bock, J. J. ;
Bond, J. R. ;
Borrill, J. ;
Bouchet, F. R. ;
Boulanger, F. ;
Bucher, M. ;
Burigana, C. ;
Butler, R. C. ;
Calabrese, E. ;
Cardoso, J. -F. ;
Carron, J. ;
Casaponsa, B. ;
Challinor, A. ;
Chiang, H. C. ;
Colombo, L. P. L. ;
Combet, C. ;
Crill, B. P. ;
Cuttaia, F. ;
de Bernardis, P. ;
de Rosa, A. ;
de Zotti, G. ;
Delabrouille, J. ;
Delouis, J. -M. ;
Di Valentino, E. ;
Diego, J. M. ;
Dore, O. ;
Douspis, M. ;
Ducout, A. ;
Dupac, X. ;
Dusini, S. ;
Efstathiou, G. ;
Elsner, F. ;
Ensslin, T. A. ;
Eriksen, H. K. ;
Fantaye, Y. ;
Fernandez-Cobos, R. .
ASTRONOMY & ASTROPHYSICS, 2020, 641
[8]   The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: DR4 maps and cosmological parameters [J].
Aiola, Simone ;
Calabrese, Erminia ;
Maurin, Loic ;
Naess, Sigurd ;
Schmitt, Benjamin L. ;
Abitbol, Maximilian H. ;
Addison, Graeme E. ;
Ade, Peter A. R. ;
Alonso, David ;
Amiri, Mandana ;
Amodeo, Stefania ;
Angile, Elio ;
Austermann, Jason E. ;
Baildon, Taylor ;
Battaglia, Nick ;
Beall, James A. ;
Bean, Rachel ;
Becker, Daniel T. ;
Bond, J. Richard ;
Bruno, Sarah Marie ;
Calafut, Victoria ;
Campusano, Luis E. ;
Carrero, Felipe ;
Chesmore, Grace E. ;
Cho, Hsiao-mei ;
Choi, Steve K. ;
Clark, Susan E. ;
Cothard, Nicholas F. ;
Crichton, Devin ;
Crowley, Kevin T. ;
Darwish, Omar ;
Datta, Rahul ;
Denison, Edward, V ;
Devlin, Mark J. ;
Duell, Cody J. ;
Duff, Shannon M. ;
Duivenvoorden, Adriaan J. ;
Dunkley, Jo ;
Dunner, Rolando ;
Essinger-Hileman, Thomas ;
Fankhanel, Max ;
Ferraro, Simone ;
Fox, Anna E. ;
Fuzia, Brittany ;
Gallardo, Patricio A. ;
Gluscevic, Vera ;
Golec, Joseph E. ;
Grace, Emily ;
Gralla, Megan ;
Guan, Yilun .
JOURNAL OF COSMOLOGY AND ASTROPARTICLE PHYSICS, 2020, (12)
[9]   NEW LOOK AT STATISTICAL-MODEL IDENTIFICATION [J].
AKAIKE, H .
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON AUTOMATIC CONTROL, 1974, AC19 (06) :716-723
[10]   EVOLUTION FREE TEST FOR NON-ZERO COSMOLOGICAL CONSTANT [J].
ALCOCK, C ;
PACZYNSKI, B .
NATURE, 1979, 281 (5730) :358-359