Addressing the Discrepancies Between Animal Models and Human Alzheimer's Disease Pathology: Implications for Translational Research

被引:8
作者
Polis, Baruh [1 ]
Samson, Abraham O. [1 ]
机构
[1] Bar Ilan Univ, Azrieli Fac Med, Safed, Israel
关键词
Aging; Alzheimer's disease; animal models; validity; AMYLOID PRECURSOR PROTEIN; NONHUMAN PRIMATE MODELS; CENTRAL-NERVOUS-SYSTEM; APOE-KNOCKOUT MICE; APOLIPOPROTEIN-E; TRANSGENIC MICE; EARLY-ONSET; WILD-TYPE; COGNITIVE DECLINE; CATHEPSIN-B;
D O I
10.3233/JAD-240058
中图分类号
Q189 [神经科学];
学科分类号
071006 ;
摘要
Animal models, particularly transgenic mice, are extensively used in Alzheimer's disease (AD) research to emulate key disease hallmarks, such as amyloid plaques and neurofibrillary tangles formation. Although these models have contributed to our understanding of AD pathogenesis and can be helpful in testing potential therapeutic interventions, their reliability is dubious. While preclinical studies have shown promise, clinical trials often yield disappointing results, highlighting a notable gap and disparity between animal models and human AD pathology. Existing models frequently overlook early-stage human pathologies and other key AD characteristics, thereby limiting their application in identifying optimal therapeutic interventions. Enhancing model reliability necessitates rigorous study design, comprehensive behavioral evaluations, and biomarker utilization. Overall, a nuanced understanding of each model's neuropathology, its fidelity to human AD, and its limitations is essential for accurate interpretation and successful translation of findings. This article analyzes the discrepancies between animal models and humanADpathology that complicate the translation of findings from preclinical studies to clinical applications. We also delve into AD pathogenesis and attributes to propose a new perspective on this pathology and deliberate over the primary limitations of key experimental models. Additionally, we discuss several fundamental problems that may explain the translational failures and suggest some possible directions for more effective preclinical studies.
引用
收藏
页码:1199 / 1218
页数:20
相关论文
共 144 条
[1]   Frequent Amyloid Deposition Without Significant Cognitive Impairment Among the Elderly [J].
Aizenstein, Howard Jay ;
Nebes, Robert D. ;
Saxton, Judith A. ;
Price, Julie C. ;
Mathis, Chester A. ;
Tsopelas, Nicholas D. ;
Ziolko, Scott K. ;
James, Jeffrey A. ;
Snitz, Beth E. ;
Houck, Patricia R. ;
Bi, Wenzhu ;
Cohen, Ann D. ;
Lopresti, Brian J. ;
DeKosky, Steven T. ;
Halligan, Edythe M. ;
Klunk, William E. .
ARCHIVES OF NEUROLOGY, 2008, 65 (11) :1509-1517
[2]   SAMP8 mice as a neuropathological model of accelerated brain aging and dementia: Toshio Takeda's legacy and future directions [J].
Akiguchi, Ichiro ;
Pallas, Merce ;
Budka, Herbert ;
Akiyama, Haruhiko ;
Ueno, Masaki ;
Han, Jingxian ;
Yagi, Hideo ;
Nishikawa, Tomohumi ;
Chiba, Yoichi ;
Sugiyama, Hiroshi ;
Takahashi, Ryoya ;
Unno, Keiko ;
Higuchi, Keiichi ;
Hosokawa, Masanori .
NEUROPATHOLOGY, 2017, 37 (04) :293-305
[3]   Frontotemporal dementia:: impact of P301L tau mutation on a healthy carrier [J].
Alberici, A ;
Gobbo, C ;
Panzacchi, A ;
Nicosia, F ;
Ghidoni, R ;
Benussi, L ;
Hock, C ;
Papassotiropoulos, A ;
Liberini, P ;
Growdon, JH ;
Frisoni, GB ;
Villa, A ;
Zanetti, O ;
Cappa, S ;
Fazio, F ;
Binetti, G .
JOURNAL OF NEUROLOGY NEUROSURGERY AND PSYCHIATRY, 2004, 75 (11) :1607-1610
[4]   2021 Alzheimer's disease facts and figures [J].
不详 .
ALZHEIMERS & DEMENTIA, 2021, 17 (03) :327-406
[5]   Posttranslational Modifications Mediate the Structural Diversity of Tauopathy Strains [J].
Arakhamia, Tamta ;
Lee, Christina E. ;
Carlomagno, Yari ;
Kumar, Mukesh ;
Duong, Duc M. ;
Wesseling, Hendrik ;
Kundinger, Sean R. ;
Wang, Kevin ;
Williams, Dewight ;
DeTure, Michael ;
Dickson, Dennis W. ;
Cook, Casey N. ;
Seyfried, Nicholas T. ;
Petrucelli, Leonard ;
Steen, Judith A. ;
Fitzpatrick, Anthony W. P. .
CELL, 2021, 184 (25) :6207-6210
[6]   Multi-metric behavioral comparison of APPsw and P30IL models for Alzheimer's Disease: linkage of poorer cognitive performance to tau pathology in forebrain [J].
Arendash, GW ;
Lewis, J ;
Leighty, RE ;
McGowan, E ;
Cracchiolo, JR ;
Hutton, M ;
Garcia, MF .
BRAIN RESEARCH, 2004, 1012 (1-2) :29-41
[7]   What determines the molecular composition of abnormal protein aggregates in neurodegenerative disease? [J].
Armstrong, Richard A. ;
Lantos, Peter L. ;
Cairns, Nigel J. .
NEUROPATHOLOGY, 2008, 28 (04) :351-365
[8]   Towards a Consensus on Alzheimer's Disease Comorbidity? [J].
Avitan, Iska ;
Halperin, Yudit ;
Saha, Trishna ;
Bloch, Naamah ;
Atrahimovich, Dana ;
Polis, Baruh ;
Samson, Abraham O. ;
Braitbard, Ori .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL MEDICINE, 2021, 10 (19)
[9]   Circle of Willis atherosclerosis: association with Alzheimer's disease, neuritic plaques and neurofibrillary tangles [J].
Beach, Thomas G. ;
Wilson, Jeffrey R. ;
Sue, Lucia I. ;
Newell, Amanda ;
Poston, Marissa ;
Cisneros, Raquel ;
Pandya, Yoga ;
Esh, Chera ;
Connor, Donald J. ;
Sabbagh, Marwan ;
Walker, Douglas G. ;
Roher, Alex E. .
ACTA NEUROPATHOLOGICA, 2007, 113 (01) :13-21
[10]   Guinea pigs as a nontransgenic model for APP processing in vitro and in vivo [J].
Beck, M ;
Bigl, V ;
Rossner, S .
NEUROCHEMICAL RESEARCH, 2003, 28 (3-4) :637-644