Phosphorus removal by free water surface constructed wetlands for the wastewater treatment: bibliometric and bibliographic review

Constructed wetlands (CWs) are a widely used technology for the treatment of wastewater, with Free Water Surface Constructed Wetlands (FWS CWs) being the simplest configuration. However, there is currently no consensus on the Hydraulic Retention Time (HRT) that optimizes P removal efficiency. To address this issue, this study conducted a bibliometric review of 85 scientific articles published between 1997 and 2021 that investigated the relationship between P removal and the HRT in FWS CWs. Scientometric maps were constructed to identify key topics, and bibliometric surveys were used to refine and explore the relationship between P removal and HRT. The analysis found a high correlation between P removal and HRT across all scales of the FWS CW systems, ranging from moderate to very strong. Specifically, the regressions between P removal efficiency and HRT were 73%, 70%, and 67% for lab-scale, pilot-scale, and real-scale systems, respectively. Overall, the FWS CWs demonstrated strong P removal efficiency, with removal rates reaching 95%, making them a promising technology for the tertiary treatment of effluents with a focus on nutrient removal and recovery. Future studies that focus on the many parameters of CW, especially on how macrophytes management affects the nutrient removal performance of these systems, are necessary to enrich our knowledge of CWs and optimize the application of this technology to wastewater treatment.