SO MUCH WRITING, SO LITTLE SCIENCE - A REVIEW OF 37 YEARS OF LITERATURE ON EDETATE SODIUM CHELATION-THERAPY

被引:39
作者
GRIER, MT
MEYERS, DG
机构
[1] UNIV NEBRASKA,MED CTR,DEPT INTERNAL MED,CARDIOL SECT,OMAHA,NE 68198
[2] UNIV NEBRASKA,MED CTR,DEPT PREVENT SOCIETAL MED,OMAHA,NE 68198
关键词
D O I
10.1177/106002809302701217
中图分类号
R9 [药学];
学科分类号
1007 ;
摘要
OBJECTIVE: To determine the safety and efficacy of edetate sodium (ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid; EDTA) chelation therapy for atherosclerosis. METHODS: Literature search using MEDLINE, encompassing 1966 through May 1993. Further references were obtained from articles and books, and from citations obtained from the American Academy of Medical Preventics. RESULTS: 16 case reports or case series, 2 longitudinal studies, and 3 clinical trials were reviewed, along with testimonials cited in 19 books. CONCLUSIONS: Little valid scientific evidence is available. Although the postulated mechanisms of action for EDTA are biologically plausible and EDTA appears to be safe, it has not been proven effective. Indeed, the best evidence shows it to be ineffective. Therefore, EDTA chelation therapy should not be used in clinical practice to treat atherosclerosis.
引用
收藏
页码:1504 / 1509
页数:6
相关论文
共 75 条
[31]   STUDIES IN COPPER STATUS AND ATHEROSCLEROSIS [J].
KINSMAN, GD ;
HOWARD, AN ;
STONE, DL ;
MULLINS, PA .
BIOCHEMICAL SOCIETY TRANSACTIONS, 1990, 18 (06) :1186-1188
[32]   POTENTIAL USES OF CHELATION METHODS IN THE TREATMENT OF CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASES [J].
KITCHELL, JR ;
MELTZER, LE ;
SEVEN, MJ .
PROGRESS IN CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASES, 1961, 3 (04) :338-349
[33]   TREATMENT OF CORONARY ARTERY DISEASE WITH DISODIUM EDTA - A REAPPRAISAL [J].
KITCHELL, JR ;
PALMON, F ;
MELTZER, LE ;
AYTAN, N .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF CARDIOLOGY, 1963, 11 (04) :501-&
[34]  
KLAASSEN CD, 1990, GOODMAN GILMANS PHAR, P1607
[35]   SOME IN VIVO EFFECTS OF CHELATION .2. ANIMAL EXPERIMENTATION [J].
KOEN, A ;
BOYLE, AJ ;
MCCANN, DS .
JOURNAL OF CHRONIC DISEASES, 1963, 16 (04) :329-+
[36]   CHELATION THERAPY OF OCCLUSIVE ARTERIOSCLEROSIS IN DIABETIC PATIENTS [J].
LAMAR, CP .
ANGIOLOGY, 1964, 15 (09) :379-+
[37]   CHELATION ENDARTERECTOMY FOR OCCLUSIVE ATHEROSCLEROSIS [J].
LAMAR, CP .
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN GERIATRICS SOCIETY, 1966, 14 (03) :272-&
[38]   RETARDATION OF ANGIOGRAPHIC PROGRESSION OF CORONARY-ARTERY DISEASE BY NIFEDIPINE - RESULTS OF THE INTERNATIONAL NIFEDIPINE TRIAL ON ANTIATHEROSCLEROTIC THERAPY (INTACT) [J].
LICHTLEN, PR ;
HUGENHOLTZ, PG ;
RAFFLENBEUL, W ;
HECKER, H ;
JOST, S ;
DECKERS, JW .
LANCET, 1990, 335 (8698) :1109-1113
[39]   COMPARISON OF NIFEDIPINE, PROPRANOLOL AND ISOSORBIDE DINITRATE ON ANGIOGRAPHIC PROGRESSION AND REGRESSION OF CORONARY ARTERIAL NARROWINGS IN ANGINA-PECTORIS [J].
LOALDI, A ;
POLESE, A ;
MONTORSI, P ;
DECESARE, N ;
FABBIOCCHI, F ;
RAVAGNANI, P ;
GUAZZI, MD .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF CARDIOLOGY, 1989, 64 (08) :433-439
[40]   CHELATION TREATMENT OF ATHEROSCLEROSIS [J].
MAGEE, R .
MEDICAL JOURNAL OF AUSTRALIA, 1985, 142 (09) :514-515