Sources of variation in post-Chernobyl radiocaesium in brown trout, Salmo trutta L., and Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus (L.), from six Cumbrian lakes (northwest England)

被引:10
作者
Elliott, J. M. [1 ]
Elliott, J. A. [1 ]
Hilton, J. [1 ]
机构
[1] NERC Inst Freshwater Ecol, Windermere Lab, Ambleside LA22 OLP, Cumbria, England
关键词
radiocaesium; brown trout; Arctic charr; Chernobyl; English Lake District;
D O I
10.1051/limn/1993009
中图分类号
Q [生物科学];
学科分类号
07 ; 0710 ; 09 ;
摘要
The objectives were to evaluate temporal variation in (137)Cs in trout and charr from Crummock Water, Wastwater, Ennerdale Water, and to compare levels in trout from six lakes (above three + Windermere, Loweswater, Devoke Water) and charr from four lakes (above three + Windermere). Fish were caught between June 1986 and October 1988, chiefly with fyke nets and gill nets. Overall means for (137)Cs in trout were markedly higher than those for charr in the three lakes. Values for individual trout exceeded 1000 Bq.kg(-1) in Ennerdale and 500 Bq.kg(-1) in Wastwater and Crummock Water, but values for charr never exceeded 350 Bq.kg(-1). (137)Cs content increased with fish weight for trout from Wastwater and therefore values were scaled to a standard weight in subsequent analyses. No similar relationships were found for trout in Ennerdale or Crummock Water, or for charr in all three lakes. Monthly mean values for (137)Cs in trout followed similar temporal patterns in the three lakes and a parabola provided a simple model for these changes. Chernobyl deposition occurred early in May 1986 and maximum values in trout were in December 1986 in Wastwater, January/February 1987 in Ennerdale Water and March 1987 in Crummock Water. The exponential rate of decrease from these maxima did not differ significantly between the three lakes, and ecological half-lives of (137)Cs in the trout differed slightly, but not significantly, between lakes : 180 days for Wastwater, 194 days for Crummock Water and 249 days for Ennerdale Water. The equivalent value for Ennerdale charr was lower at 132 days, and it was impossible to fit models or calculate half-lives for Wastwater and Crummock charr. Maximum monthly geometric mean (137)Cs values in trout from six lakes and charr from four lakes were related to the initial concentration of (137)Cs in both water and sediment, and the maximum monthly geometric mean (137)Cs values obtained from the routine water samples. The relationship was curvilinear and approximated, but was not identical to, an asymptotic curve. No similar relationships were found with mean Ca or K levels in the lake water. Metabolic and diet differences may explain the lower (137)Cs levels in charr compared with trout and differences for the same species from different lakes may be due to limnological variations and differences between lakes in the nature of their sediments and catchment soils. Both points are discussed in detail.
引用
收藏
页码:79 / 98
页数:20
相关论文
共 47 条
[31]  
LINDNER G, 1990, BROCK SPR S, P265
[32]   SOME OBSERVATIONS ON SEASONAL-VARIATION OF RADIOCESIUM CONTAMINATION IN TROUT (SALMO-TRUTTA L) AND ARCTIC CHAR (SALVELINUS-ALPINUS (L) IN A NORWEGIAN LAKE AFTER THE CHERNOBYL FALLOUT [J].
LONVIK, K ;
KOKSVIK, JI .
HYDROBIOLOGIA, 1990, 190 (02) :121-125
[33]  
LUUKKO A, 1989, P C RAD HIGH TATR, P157
[34]   The Chernobyl reactor accident and the aquatic environment of the UK: A fisheries viewpoint [J].
Mitchell, N.T. ;
Camplin, W.C. ;
Leonard, D.R.P. .
Journal of the Society for Radiological Protection, 1986, 6 (04) :167-172
[35]  
OHNSTAD FR, 1982, FRESHWAT BIOL ASS OC, V15
[37]   EFFECTS OF TEMPERATURE AND DIFFERENT FOOD ORGANISMS ON THE RATE OF GASTRIC EVACUATION IN PERCH (PERCA-FLUVIATILIS) [J].
PERSSON, L .
FRESHWATER BIOLOGY, 1979, 9 (02) :99-104
[38]   CONCENTRATION FACTORS USED IN THE ASSESSMENT OF RADIATION-DOSE TO CONSUMERS OF FISH - A REVIEW OF 27 RADIONUCLIDES [J].
POSTON, TM ;
KLOPFER, DC .
HEALTH PHYSICS, 1988, 55 (05) :751-766
[39]   CONCENTRATIONS OF CAESIUM-137 AND STRONTIUM-90 IN FLESH OF BROWN TROUT TAKEN FROM RIVERS AND LAKES IN BRITISH ISLES BETWEEN 1961 AND 1966 - VARIABLES DETERMINING CONCENTRATIONS AND THEIR USE IN RADIOLOGICAL ASSESSMENTS [J].
PRESTON, A ;
JEFFRIES, DF ;
DUTTON, JWR .
WATER RESEARCH, 1967, 1 (07) :475-&
[40]  
RAMSBOTTOM AE, 1976, SCI PUBLS FRESHWAT B, V33