CHRONIC PAIN - THE END OF THE WELFARE-STATE

被引:28
作者
NACHEMSON, A
机构
关键词
DISABILITY; LOW BACK PAIN; PSYCHOSOCIAL FACTORS; TREATMENT;
D O I
10.1007/BF00433370
中图分类号
R19 [保健组织与事业(卫生事业管理)];
学科分类号
摘要
The problem of low back pain has reached epidemic proportions in the industrialized nations. The predicament of back pain is common, 30-40% of our populations from 10-65 years old report such trouble to occur on a monthly basis. In 1-8% this results in work-disabling back pain. Only in very few of these patients can physicians diagnose a definite pathoanatomical cause for the pain. It can be deduced that psychosocial factors, including insurance benefits are of importance for this variation, Sweden, with 100% sickness benefits, has the highest disability rate. Few non-surgical methods have proven effective in rendering the patient better for him to return to work. Even fewer studies demonstrate any benefit from surgery, simple open removal of a proven disc hernia being the only exception. For patients with unproven diagnostic labels such as facet arthritis, degenerative disc disease, internal disc resorption and instability, no evidence exists that any type of surgery is cost-effective. More attention must be paid to illness behaviour by anyone treating chronic low back pain syndromes (> 3 months), Such psychological reactions to an originally nociceptive pain stimulus somewhere in the motion segment, must be elucidated and addressed, before embarking on risky and expensive treatment modalities including surgery. It is time for all of us, politicians as well as physicians, to distinguish what types of support will contribute to our nations' future and which ones will undermine it, Our welfare systems are at stake.
引用
收藏
页码:S11 / S17
页数:7
相关论文
共 58 条
[41]  
OSIGNERAD, 1988, REPETITIVE STRAIN IN
[42]  
OSTERWEIS M, 1987, CLIN BEHAVIORAL PUBL
[43]  
OSTGAARD HC, 1991, SPINE, V16, P132
[44]   AUTOMATED PERCUTANEOUS LUMBAR DISCECTOMY VERSUS CHEMONUCLEOLYSIS IN THE TREATMENT OF SCIATICA - A RANDOMIZED MULTICENTER TRIAL [J].
REVEL, M ;
PAYAN, C ;
VALLEE, C ;
LAREDO, JD ;
LASSALE, B ;
ROUX, C ;
CARTER, H ;
SALOMON, C ;
DELMAS, E ;
ROUCOULES, J ;
BEAUVAIS, C ;
SAVY, JM ;
CHICHEPORTICHE, V ;
BOURGEOIS, P ;
SMADJA, M ;
HERCOT, O ;
WYBIER, M ;
CAGAN, G ;
BLUMBOISGARD, C ;
FERMANIAN, J .
SPINE, 1993, 18 (01) :1-7
[45]   WORKER INJURIES - THE EFFECTS OF WORKERS COMPENSATION AND OSHA INSPECTIONS [J].
ROBERTSON, LS ;
KEEVE, JP .
JOURNAL OF HEALTH POLITICS POLICY AND LAW, 1983, 8 (03) :581-597
[46]  
Sandstedt P, 1989, Lakartidningen, V86, P1159
[47]   SPINAL MANIPULATION FOR LOW-BACK-PAIN [J].
SHEKELLE, PG ;
ADAMS, AH ;
CHASSIN, MR ;
HURWITZ, EL ;
BROOK, RH .
ANNALS OF INTERNAL MEDICINE, 1992, 117 (07) :590-598
[48]  
TAYOR VM, UNPUB SPINE
[49]  
TROUP DG, 1981, SPINE, V6, P61
[50]  
VALLFORS B, 1985, SCAND J REHAB MED S, P11