SYSTEMATIC-ERROR IN BEHAVIORAL MEASUREMENT - COMPARING RESULTS FROM INTERVIEW AND TIME BUDGET STUDIES

被引:76
作者
NIEMI, I
机构
[1] Statistics Finland, Helsinki
关键词
D O I
10.1007/BF01078729
中图分类号
C [社会科学总论];
学科分类号
03 ; 0303 ;
摘要
Data collected by survey methodology are sensitive to measurement errors. Factors of memory, understanding, and willingness to respond truthfully, distort the quality of results. In this paper, time diaries were used as a quality check for results obtained by direct interviews and questionnaires. Data is based on surveys carried out by Statistics Finland. Comparison showed that measurement error varied considerably between population groups, influencing dependencies and interpretations of the results. Activities clearly distinctive from other activities, such as gainful employment outside the home, produced the most accurate data in direct survey questions. Everyday activities that don't clearly stand out from other uses of time, such as home based employment, are difficult to recall and produce a lot of biasing measurement errors.
引用
收藏
页码:229 / 244
页数:16
相关论文
共 14 条
[1]  
BATESON N, 1984, CONT SOCIAL RES SERI, V10
[2]  
BELSON WA, 1981, DESIGN UNDERSTANDING
[3]  
Bradburn NM, 1980, IMPROVING INTERVIEW
[4]  
ESKOLA K, 1979, THESIS U HELSINKI HE
[5]  
*FINLAND CENTR STA, 1990, CULT MED, V2
[6]  
GALTUNG J, 1970, THEORY METHOD SOCIAL
[7]  
HIETALA M, 1982, TUTKIJAN TILASTOLLIS, P7
[8]  
NIEMI I, 1985, TILASTOKESKUS TUTKIM
[9]  
NIEMI I, 1983, STATISTICAL REV, V4, P326
[10]  
PHILLIPS D, 1973, SOCIOLOGICAL STUDIES