Comparative study of the performance of Islamic and conventional banks The case of Malaysia

被引:37
作者
Wasiuzzaman, Shaista [1 ]
Gunasegavan, Umadevi [2 ]
机构
[1] Multimedia Univ, Fac Management, Cyberjaya, Malaysia
[2] Multimedia Univ, MBA Ctr, Cyberjaya, Malaysia
关键词
Performance; Islamic bank; Corporate governance; Economic conditions; Banks; Malaysia;
D O I
10.1108/08288661311299312
中图分类号
F [经济];
学科分类号
02 ;
摘要
Purpose - The aim of this paper is to analyze the differences in bank characteristics of Islamic and conventional banks in Malaysia, especially when it comes to their profitability, capital adequacy, liquidity, operational efficiency and asset quality are also considered. Corporate governance issues and economic conditions are also included in the analysis. Design/methodology/approach - A total of 14 banks (nine conventional and five Islamic) were considered over the period of 2005- 2009. Three stages of analysis were performed. First, descriptive statistics were computed to understand the differences in characteristics of the two types of banks. Next, to determine whether these differences were significant, independent t- tests were carried out on each variable. Finally, regression analysis was carried out to analyze the effect of the variables on bank profitability. Findings - It is found that the return on average assets, bank size and board size values of conventional banks was higher compared to Islamic banks. The other variables-operational efficiency, asset quality, liquidity, capital adequacy and board independence-were higher for Islamic banks. Significant differences between the two bank types were found for all the variables, except for profitability and board independence. All variables except for liquidity, board characteristics and type of bank, were found to be highly significant in affecting profitability. Originality/value - This paper looks at the differences between Islamic and conventional banking systems in Malaysia. Contrasting results were found for the independent t-tests and regression analysis, which makes it an interesting study that should be pursued further.
引用
收藏
页码:43 / 60
页数:18
相关论文
共 50 条
[41]   Payout policy and ownership structure: The case of Islamic and conventional banks [J].
Duqi, Andi ;
Jaafar, Aziz ;
Warsame, Mohammed H. .
BRITISH ACCOUNTING REVIEW, 2020, 52 (01)
[42]   Loan loss provisions, bank valuations and discretion: A comparative study between conventional and Islamic banks [J].
Elnahass, Marwa ;
Izzeldin, Marwan ;
Abdelsalam, Omneya .
JOURNAL OF ECONOMIC BEHAVIOR & ORGANIZATION, 2014, 103 :S160-S173
[43]   Nexus between corporate governance and FinTech disclosure: a comparative study between conventional and Islamic banks [J].
Shehadeh, Maha ;
Ahmed, Fatma ;
Hussainey, Khaled ;
Alkaraan, Fadi .
COMPETITIVENESS REVIEW, 2024,
[44]   Relationship between capital, risk and efficiency A comparative study between Islamic and conventional banks of Bangladesh [J].
Miah, Md. Dulal ;
Sharmeen, Kashfia .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ISLAMIC AND MIDDLE EASTERN FINANCE AND MANAGEMENT, 2015, 8 (02) :203-221
[45]   Impact of COVID-19 on bank performance: a comparison between Islamic vs conventional banks in OIC countries [J].
Alhaddab, Abdulaziz ;
Hassan, M. Kabir ;
Hasan, Rashedul .
ACCOUNTING RESEARCH JOURNAL, 2025,
[46]   Stakeholder Returns of Islamic Banks Versus Conventional Banks [J].
Ozdincer, Begumhan ;
Yuce, Ayse .
EMERGING MARKETS FINANCE AND TRADE, 2018, 54 (14) :3330-3350
[47]   Islamic Estate Planning (IEP) in Malaysia: The Opportunities for Islamic Banks [J].
Hassan, Rusni ;
Zaaba, Nurul 'Iffah M. A. .
INNOVATION OF BUSINESSES, AND DIGITALIZATION DURING COVID-19 PANDEMIC, ICBT 2021, 2023, 488 :223-230
[48]   Impact of Audit Committee Quality on the Financial Performance of Conventional and Islamic Banks [J].
Haddad, Achraf ;
El Ammari, Anis ;
Bouri, Abdelfattah .
JOURNAL OF RISK AND FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT, 2021, 14 (04)
[49]   Financial performance of Islamic and conventional banks in MENA region: a GLS approach [J].
Jarbou, Samah Ibrahim ;
Irimia-Dieguez, Ana ;
Prieto-Rodriguez, Manuela .
JOURNAL OF ISLAMIC ACCOUNTING AND BUSINESS RESEARCH, 2024,
[50]   Relationship between capital, risk and liquidity: a comparative study between Islamic and conventional banks in MENA region [J].
Mahdi, Ines Ben Salah ;
Abbes, Mouna Boujelbene .
RESEARCH IN INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS AND FINANCE, 2018, 45 :588-596