Interpreting Bounded Rationality in Business and Industrial Marketing Contexts: Executive Training Case Studies

被引:2
|
作者
Woodside, Arch G. [1 ]
Lai, Wen-Hsiang [2 ]
Kim, Kyung Hoon [3 ]
Jung, Deuk Keyo [3 ]
机构
[1] Boston Coll, Carroll Sch Management, Dept Mkt, 140 Commonwealth Ave, Chestnut Hill, MA 02467 USA
[2] Feng Chia Univ, Business Sch, Grad Inst Management Technol, Taichung 407, Taiwan
[3] Changwon Natl Univ, Dept Business Adm, Chang Won, Gyeongnam, South Korea
关键词
Bounded rationality; Decision system analysis; Original equipment manufacturer; Thematic organization packets; Contingency thinking streams; Aspiration adaptation theory;
D O I
10.1080/12297119.2009.9707298
中图分类号
F [经济];
学科分类号
02 ;
摘要
This article provides training exercises for executives into interpreting subroutine maps of executives thinking in processing business and industrial marketing problems and opportunities. This study builds on premises that Schank proposes about learning and teaching including (1) learning occurs by experiencing and the best instruction offers learners opportunities to distill their knowledge and skills from interactive stories in the form of goal-based scenarios, team projects, and understanding stories from experts. Also, (2) telling does not lead to learning because learning requires actiontraining environments should emphasize active engagement with stories, cases, and projects. Each training case study includes executive exposure to decision system analysis (DSA). The training case requires the executive to write a Briefing Report of a DSA map. Instructions to the executive trainee in writing the briefing report include coverage in the briefing report of (1) details of the essence of the DSA map and (2) a statement of warnings and opportunities that the executive map reader interprets within the DSA map. The length maximum for a briefing report is 500 wordsan arbitrary rule that works well in executive training programs Following this introduction, section two of the article briefly summarizes relevant literature on how humans think within contexts in response to problems and opportunities. Section three illustrates the creation and interpreting of DSA maps using a training exercise in pricing a chemical product to different OEM (original equipment manufacturer) customers. Section four presents a training exercise in pricing decisions by a petroleum manufacturing firm. Section five presents a training exercise in marketing strategies by an office furniture distributer along with buying strategies by business customers. Each of the three training exercises is based on research into information processing and decision making of executives operating in marketing contexts. Section six concludes the article with suggestions for use of this training case and for developing additional training cases for honing executives decisionmaking skills. Todd and Gigerenzer propose that humans use simple heuristics because they enable adaptive behavior by exploiting the structure of information in natural decision environments. Simplicity is a virtue, rather than a curse. Bounded rationality theorists emphasize the centrality of Simon's proposition, Human rational behavior is shaped by a scissors whose blades are the structure of the task environments and the computational capabilities of the actor. Gigerenzer's view is relevant to Simon's environmental blade and to the environmental structures in the three cases in this article, The term environment, here, does not refer to a description of the total physical and biological environment, but only to that part important to an organism, given its needs and goals. The present article directs attention to research that combines reports on the structure of task environments with the use of adaptive toolbox heuristics of actors. The DSA mapping approach here concerns the match between strategy and an environmentthe development and understanding of ecological rationality theory. Aspiration adaptation theoty is central to this approach. Aspiration adaptation theoiy models decision making as a multi-goal problem without aggregation of the goals into a complete preference order over all decision alternatives. The three case studies in this article permit the learner to apply propositions in aspiration level rules in reaching a decision. Aspiration adaptation takes the form of a sequence of adjustment steps. An adjustment step shifts the current aspiration level to a neighboring point on an aspiration grid by a change in only one goal variable. An upward adjustment step is an increase and a downward adjustment step is a decrease of a goal variable. Creating and using aspiration adaptation levels is integral to bounded rationality theory . The present article increases understanding and expertise of both aspiration adaptation and bounded rationality theories by providing tearner experiences and practice in using propositions in both theories. Practice in ranking CTSs and writing TOP gists from DSA maps serves to clarify and deepen Selten's view, Clearly, aspiration adaptation must enter the picture as an integrated part of the search for a solution. The body of direct research by Mintzberg, Gladwin's ethnographic decision tree modeling, and Huffs work on mapping strategic thought are suggestions on where to look for research that considers both the structure of the environment and the computational capabilities of the actors making decisions in these environments. Such research on bounded rationality permits both further development of theory in how and why decisions are made in real - life and the development of learning exercises in the use of heuristics occurring in natural environments. The exercises in the present article encourage learning skills and principles of using fast and frugal heuristics in contexts of their intended use. The exercises respond to Schank's wisdom, In a deep sense, education isn't about knowledge or getting students to know what has happened. It is about getting them to feel what has happened. This is not easy to do. Education, as it is in schools today, is emotionless. This is a huge problem. The three cases and accompanying set of exercise questions adhere to Schank's view, Processes are best taught by actually engaging in them, which can often mean, for mental processing, active discussion."
引用
收藏
页码:49 / 61
页数:13
相关论文
共 9 条
  • [1] Bounded Rationality, Uncertainty, and Complexity as Decision-Making Contexts: A Case of One University in Russia
    Drugova, Elena A.
    Kalachikova, Olga N.
    EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF CONTEMPORARY EDUCATION, 2019, 8 (04): : 738 - 750
  • [2] Theory Building, Case Dependence, and Researchers' Bounded Rationality: An Illustration From Studies of Innovation Diffusion
    Oliveira, Nuno
    Secchi, Davide
    SOCIOLOGICAL METHODS & RESEARCH, 2023, 52 (02) : 993 - 1042
  • [3] EDUCATION VS TRAINING IN BUSINESS SCHOOLS - THE CASE OF INDUSTRIAL-RELATIONS
    GODARD, J
    REVUE CANADIENNE DES SCIENCES DE L ADMINISTRATION-CANADIAN JOURNAL OF ADMINISTRATIVE SCIENCES, 1992, 9 (03): : 238 - 252
  • [4] Mobile Marketing Training towards Increasing Business: A Case Study of Agri-Food Micro-Enterprises
    Othman, Zakirah
    Zaman, Nur Badriyah Kamarul
    Abu, Noor Hidayah
    Abdullah, Syahida
    Alias, Emmy Farha
    Jahroh, Siti
    International Journal of Interactive Mobile Technologies, 2024, 18 (14) : 59 - 71
  • [5] Training business students to be end-used developers: Are case studies the best option?
    Barker, SK
    ISSUES AND TRENDS OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY MANAGEMENT IN CONTEMPORARY ORGANIZATIONS, VOLS 1 AND 2, 2002, : 62 - 65
  • [6] USE OF CASE-STUDIES IN-TRAINING ON INFORMATION-SYSTEMS FOR BUSINESS AND MANAGEMENT
    KONIG, W
    WIRTSCHAFTSINFORMATIK, 1994, 36 (05): : 511 - 511
  • [7] FINANCE, MARKETING, MANAGEMENT AND STRATEGY PLANNING A QUALITATIVE RESEARCH METHOD ANALYSIS OF CASE STUDIES IN BUSINESS HOTELS IN PATRAS AND IN ATHENS
    Kopaneli, Anastasia
    ECONOMIES OF BALKAN AND EASTERN EUROPE COUNTRIES IN THE CHANGED WORLD (EBEEC 2013), 2014, 9 : 472 - 487
  • [8] SPONTANEOUS QUESTIONING IN VIDEO-ENHANCED TRAINING SITUATIONS: TWO CASE STUDIES INVOLVING CONTRASTED CONTEXTS OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE
    Vilches, Vincent Alonso
    Verpoorten, Dominique
    Detroz, Pascal
    Pirard, Florence
    TRAVAIL HUMAIN, 2021, 84 (04): : 321 - 347
  • [9] Study on the Training Mode for the Business Administration Professionals in the Application-Oriented Colleges Based on the Principle of Marketing - A Case Study Based on the Practices of Tianjin Tianshi College
    CAO, Jiawei
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2018 EURO-ASIA CONFERENCE ON ENVIRONMENT AND CSR: TOURISM, SOCIETY AND EDUCATION SESSION (PART III), 2018, : 126 - 133