A removal torque and histomorphometric study of commercially pure niobium and titanium implants in rabbit bone

Screw-shaped commercially pure (c.p.) niobium and c.p. titanium implants were inserted in rabbit bone. After a healing period of 3 months, a significantly higher removal torque was demonstrated to unscrew the niobium implants (average 32.9 Ncm) compared to the c.p. titanium implants (average 25.3 Ncm). In the histomorphometric part of the study, there were no significant differences in bone-to-metal contact between the 2 implant materials. An average of 41.1% bony contact was demonstrated for the niobium screws compared to an average 37.2% for the c.p. titanium ones. Our removal torque findings could be related to the differences that we observed between the 2 implant surfaces as indicated by SEM. Since niobium implants showed a more irregular surface topography and niobium is a softer metal than c.p. titanium, this seems the most probable reason for the differences observed in removal torque between the 2 metals. Hypothetically, a more "positive biocompatibility" of the c.p. niobium in comparison the c.p. titanium remains as another possible reason for the observed differences. However, against such a differences in biocompatibility between c.p. niobium and c.p. titanium there is the very similar amount of bony contact registered in the histomorphometric analysis