COMPARISON OF ADENOSINE, DIPYRIDAMOLE, AND DOBUTAMINE IN STRESS ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY

被引:161
作者
MARTIN, TW [1 ]
SEAWORTH, JF [1 ]
JOHNS, JP [1 ]
PUPA, LE [1 ]
CONDOS, WR [1 ]
机构
[1] BROOKE ARMY MED CTR, FT SAM HOUSTON, TX 78234 USA
关键词
ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY; DOBUTAMINE; DIPYRIDAMOLE; ADENOSINE; EXERCISE TEST;
D O I
10.7326/0003-4819-116-3-190
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Objective: To compare adenosine, dipyridamole, and dobutamine in stress echocardiography with regard to sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, and side effects. Design: Crossover, blinded comparison, with coronary angiography serving as the criterion standard. Setting: U.S. Army tertiary care hospital. Participants: Forty participants, 25 with coronary disease and 15 without coronary disease. Patients were eligible if they had coronary angiography within 6 weeks of stress testing or if they had a risk for coronary disease of less than 5%. Measurements: Left ventricular wall motion was recorded after dobutamine (0.38 mg/kg body weight), adenosine (0.84 mg/kg body weight), and dipyridamole (0.84 mg/kg body weight) stress testing. Stress echocardiographic evaluation was considered to be abnormal if the patient developed new or progressive wall motion abnormalities. The rate of side effects for the types of echocardiography and the patient preference were recorded. Main Results: The sensitivity of dobutamine stress echocardiography (76%; 95% Cl, 59% to 93%) was significantly higher than that of adenosine echocardiography (40%; Cl, 21% to 59%; P < 0.001) and that of dipyridamole echocardiography (56%; Cl, 37% to 75%; P = 0.019). The specificity of adenosine testing (93%; Cl, 80% to 100%) was significantly higher than that of dobutamine echocardiography (60%; Cl, 35% to 85%; P = 0.008) and that of dipyridamole echocardiography (67%; Cl, 43% to 91 %; P = 0.028). Symptoms were more frequent with adenosine echocardiography (100%) than with dipyridamole (88%; P< 0.001) or dobutamine (80%; P < 0.001) echocardiography. Treatment for persistent symptoms was required in more patients after dipyridamole echocardiography (40%) than after dobutamine (12%; P < 0.001) or adenosine (0%; P < .001) echocardiography. More patients preferred dobutamine (48%) or dipyridamole (40%) echocardiography to adenosine echocardiography (12%; P < .001). Conclusions: Dobutamine stress echocardiography is more sensitive and is better tolerated than adenosine or dipyridamole stress echocardiography. Adenosine echocardiography is more specific than dobutamine or dipyridamole echocardiography and is less likely to cause persistent symptoms.
引用
收藏
页码:190 / 196
页数:7
相关论文
共 50 条
[31]   REPRODUCIBILITY OF THE DOBUTAMINE-ATROPINE ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY STRESS TEST [J].
BELLOTTI, P ;
FIORETTI, PM ;
FORSTER, T ;
MCNEILL, AJ ;
ELSAID, ESM ;
SALUSTRI, A ;
ROELANDT, JRTC .
ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY-A JOURNAL OF CARDIOVASCULAR ULTRASOUND AND ALLIED TECHNIQUES, 1993, 10 (01) :93-97
[32]   UNUSUAL SIDE-EFFECT OF A DOBUTAMINE STRESS ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY [J].
FRIART, A ;
HERMANS, L ;
DEVALERIOLA, Y .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF NONINVASIVE CARDIOLOGY, 1993, 7 (01) :63-64
[33]   Methodological analysis of diagnostic dobutamine stress echocardiography studies [J].
Krenning, BJ ;
Geleijnse, ML ;
Poldermans, D ;
Roelandt, JRTC .
ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY-A JOURNAL OF CARDIOVASCULAR ULTRASOUND AND ALLIED TECHNIQUES, 2004, 21 (08) :725-736
[34]   Dobutamine stress echocardiography: a review and update [J].
Gilstrap, Lauren Gray ;
Bhatia, R. Sacha ;
Weiner, Rory B. ;
Dudzinski, David M. .
RESEARCH REPORTS IN CLINICAL CARDIOLOGY, 2014, 5 :69-80
[35]   Dobutamine stress echocardiography in hypertrophic cardiomyopathy [J].
Losi, MA ;
Betocchi, S ;
Aversa, M ;
Lombardi, R ;
Miranda, M ;
Cacace, A ;
Ciampi, Q ;
Tocchetti, CG ;
Guida, A ;
Chiariello, M .
CARDIOLOGY, 2003, 100 (02) :93-100
[36]   Noninvasive prediction of coronary artery disease progression by comparison of serial exercise electrocardiography and dipyridamole stress echocardiography [J].
Rodriguez, O ;
Picano, E ;
Fedele, S ;
Morelos, M ;
Marzilli, M .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CARDIOVASCULAR IMAGING, 2002, 18 (02) :93-99
[37]   Noninvasive prediction of coronary artery disease progression by comparison of serial exercise electrocardiography and dipyridamole stress echocardiography [J].
Olaf Rodriguez ;
Eugenio Picano ;
Silvio Fedele ;
Martha Morelos ;
Mario Marzilli .
The International Journal of Cardiovascular Imaging, 2002, 18 :93-99
[38]   Comparison of Hyperemic Impedance Echocardiography with Dobutamine Stress Echocardiography to Detect Inducible Myocardial Ischemia: A Pilot Study [J].
Patel, Jijibhoy J. ;
Gupta, Ankur ;
Nanda, Navin C. .
ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY-A JOURNAL OF CARDIOVASCULAR ULTRASOUND AND ALLIED TECHNIQUES, 2016, 33 (03) :416-420
[39]   Blunted increase in plasma adenosine levels following dipyridamole stress in dilated cardiomyopathy patients [J].
Laghi-Pasini, F ;
Guideri, F ;
Petersen, C ;
Lazzerini, PE ;
Sicari, R ;
Capecchi, PL ;
Picano, E .
JOURNAL OF INTERNAL MEDICINE, 2003, 254 (06) :591-596
[40]   Dipyridamole stress echocardiography: State of the art 1996 [J].
Picano, E ;
Ostojic, M ;
Sicari, R ;
Baroni, M ;
Cortigiani, L ;
Pingitore, A .
EUROPEAN HEART JOURNAL, 1997, 18 :D16-D23