'Pervaded by a chill': (1) The dialectic of coldness in Adorno's social theory

This article examines some of the ways in which the trope of coldness appears in the social theory of Theodor W. Adorno. In the first section, I show how and why Adorno repeatedly criticizes a certain brand of coldness, namely, 'bourgeois coldness', which is understood as enacting and encouraging formal abstraction and indifference to sensuous particularity. In this sense, coldness is seen to function as a precondition for severe forms of violence (both symbolic and material). However, in the second section, I argue that stopping short at this one-sided 'critique of coldness' remains incomplete and undialectical, and does not do justice to Adorno's more complicated engagement with the topic. In light of this, I invert the focus of analysis to the 'coldness of critique', claiming that there are examples of other forms, internalizations and uses of coldness in Adorno's work, serving to indefatigably expand the utopian horizons of his social theory above and beyond piecemeal reformism, local pedagogy or pragmatic micro-politics. The aim is not simply to promote ostensibly 'positive' alternatives or remedies to the 'negative' symptom of coldness, but rather to tarry with the negative, to recognize the coldness within ourselves the better to break through and sublate it. For Adorno, there is no way around coldness; the only way is to go through it.