TREATMENT OF ACTIVE CROHNS-DISEASE BY EXCLUSION DIET - EAST ANGLIAN MULTICENTER CONTROLLED TRIAL

被引:144
作者
RIORDAN, AM
HUNTER, JO
COWAN, RE
CRAMPTON, JR
DAVIDSON, AR
DICKINSON, RJ
DRONFIELD, MW
FELLOWS, IW
HISHON, S
KERRIGAN, GNW
KENNEDY, HJ
MCGOURAN, RCM
NEALE, G
SAUNDERS, JHB
机构
[1] ADDENBROOKES HOSP,DEPT GASTROENTEROL,GASTROENTEROL RES UNIT,CAMBRIDGE CB2 2QQ,ENGLAND
[2] COLCHESTER GEN HOSP,COLCHESTER,ENGLAND
[3] KETTERING & DIST GEN HOSP,KETTERING NN16 8UZ,NORTHANTS,ENGLAND
[4] HINCHINGBROOKE HOSP,HUNTINGDON,ENGLAND
[5] PETERBOROUGH DIST GEN HOSP,PETERBOROUGH PE3 6DA,ENGLAND
[6] NORFOLK & NORWICH HOSP,NORWICH NR1 3SR,NORFOLK,ENGLAND
[7] JAMES PAGET HOSP,GORLESTON,ENGLAND
[8] W SUFFOLK HOSP,BURY ST EDMUNDS,ENGLAND
[9] QUEEN ELIZABETH HOSP,KINGS LYNN,ENGLAND
[10] BEDFORD HOSP,BEDFORD,ENGLAND
关键词
D O I
10.1016/0140-6736(93)92121-9
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Elemental diet is as effective in producing remission of Crohn's disease (CD) as is corticosteroid treatment, but most patients relapse soon after resumption of a normal diet. We have investigated the efficacies of dietary modification and oral corticosteroids in maintaining remission achieved with elemental diet. In a multicentre trial, 136 patients with active CD were started on elemental diet and other treatment was withdrawn. 43 (31%) declined to continue elemental diet for 14 days, but 78 (84%) of the remaining 93 achieved remission and were randomly assigned corticosteroids (38) or diet (40). Corticosteroid treatment started at 40 mg prednisolone daily, which was tapered and stopped after 12 weeks; that group received dietary advice on healthy eating. The diet group received ''tapered'' placebo and were instructed to introduce one new food daily, excluding any that precipitated symptoms. Assessment of progress for up to 2 years was made by physicians unaware of group assignment. Intention-to-treat analysis showed median lengths of remission of 3.8 (interquartile range 5.0) months in the corticosteroid group and 7.5 (15.3) months on diet, and relapse rates at 2 years, adjusted for withdrawals, of 79% and 62%, respectively (p=0.048). Clinical improvement in the diet group was associated with significant changes in plasma albumin and alpha1-antichymotrypsin concentrations and erythrocyte sedimentation rate. Food intolerances discovered were predominantly to cereals, dairy products, and yeast. Diet provides a further therapeutic strategy in active Crohn's disease.
引用
收藏
页码:1131 / 1134
页数:4
相关论文
共 13 条
[1]   CONTROLLED TRIAL OF POLYMERIC VERSUS ELEMENTAL DIET IN TREATMENT OF ACTIVE CROHNS-DISEASE [J].
GIAFFER, MH ;
NORTH, G ;
HOLDSWORTH, CD .
LANCET, 1990, 335 (8693) :816-819
[2]  
HARVEY RF, 1980, LANCET, V1, P514
[3]  
JONES VA, 1985, LANCET, V2, P177
[4]  
KELLY SM, 1989, SCAND J GASTR S158, V24, P149
[5]   COMPARISON OF ENTERAL NUTRITION AND DRUG-TREATMENT IN ACTIVE CROHNS-DISEASE - RESULTS OF THE EUROPEAN COOPERATIVE CROHNS-DISEASE STUDY .4. [J].
LOCHS, H ;
STEINHARDT, HJ ;
KLAUSWENTZ, B ;
ZEITZ, M ;
VOGELSANG, H ;
SOMMER, H ;
FLEIG, WE ;
BAUER, P ;
SCHIRRMEISTER, J ;
MALCHOW, H .
GASTROENTEROLOGY, 1991, 101 (04) :881-888
[6]   FEASIBILITY AND EFFECTIVENESS OF A DEFINED-FORMULA DIET REGIMEN IN TREATING ACTIVE CROHNS-DISEASE - EUROPEAN COOPERATIVE CROHNS-DISEASE STUDY .3. [J].
MALCHOW, H ;
STEINHARDT, HJ ;
LORENZMEYER, H ;
STROHM, WD ;
RASMUSSEN, S ;
SOMMER, H ;
JARNUM, S ;
BRANDES, JW ;
LEONHARDT, H ;
EWE, K ;
JESDINSKY, H .
SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF GASTROENTEROLOGY, 1990, 25 (03) :235-244
[7]  
MIDDLETON SJ, 1991, GUT, V32, pA578
[8]   ELEMENTAL DIET AS PRIMARY-TREATMENT OF ACUTE CROHNS-DISEASE - A CONTROLLED TRIAL [J].
OMORAIN, C ;
SEGAL, AW ;
LEVI, AJ .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1984, 288 (6434) :1859-1862
[9]   CONTROLLED TRIAL COMPARING 2 TYPES OF ENTERAL NUTRITION IN TREATMENT OF ACTIVE CROHNS-DISEASE - ELEMENTAL NU-POLYMERIC DIET [J].
RIGAUD, D ;
COSNES, J ;
LEQUINTREC, Y ;
RENE, E ;
GENDRE, JP ;
MIGNON, M .
GUT, 1991, 32 (12) :1492-1497
[10]   IMPROVEMENT OF ABNORMAL LACTULOSE RHAMNOSE PERMEABILITY IN ACTIVE CROHNS-DISEASE OF THE SMALL-BOWEL BY AN ELEMENTAL DIET [J].
SANDERSON, IR ;
BOULTON, P ;
MENZIES, I ;
WALKERSMITH, JA .
GUT, 1987, 28 (09) :1073-1076