CARCINOMA OF THE CERVICAL STUMP - A REVIEW OF 213 CASES

From 1970 to 1987, 213 cases of carcinoma of the cervical stump were accrued in a multi-institutional prospective cooperative study. This group accounted for 5.5% of cervical carcinoma diagnosed during the same period. 13 had in situ carcinoma and 200 had invasive carcinoma (96% squamous cell carcinoma, 4% adenocarcinoma). Radiotherapy alone (external and brachytherapy) was given to 77%, brachytherapy and surgery to 15% and surgery alone to 8%). FIGO stage distribution was: I (31%), IIa (15%), IIb (27%), IIIa (5%), IIIb (17%) and IV (5%). Five-year locoregional control per stage was 100% in Ia, 85% in Ib, 82% in IIa, 71% in IIb, 45% in IIIa, 54% in IIIb and 30% in IV. Corrected 5-year survival per stage was 82% in Ib, 78% in IIa, 73% in IIb, 69% in IIIa, 38% in IIIb and 0% in IV. The diameter of disease in stage II strongly influenced the 5-year locoregional control (81% for tumours of less than 3 cm vs. 68% for tumours more than 3 cm). Lymphangiogram was associated with a 44.5% 5-year locoregional control when positive vs. 74% when non-positive. Brachytherapy was advantageous in obtaining locoregional control in patients receiving external irradiation and brachytherapy: 81.5% vs. 38.5% in patients treated with external radiotherapy alone. Surgery was performed only for in situ carcinoma and for part of stages Ia, Ib and IIa. There is no significant difference in locoregional control at equal stage between radiotherapy alone and treatment schemes including surgery. However, lethal complications were observed in 6% of the patients of the surgical group as compared to 0.6% of the patients treated with radiotherapy alone. Radical radiotherapy seems to provide similar results of locoregional control and survival at equal stages in carcinoma of the cervical stump compared to carcinoma developed on an intact uterus. The rate of severe complications reported with the French-Italian glossary is 13% for G3 and 3% for G4, which is close to the observed rate during the same period in our series of radical radiotherapy to the intact uterus.