Relationships among food security, produce intake and behaviors, health, and social capital in rural Appalachian community gardeners were examined. Gardeners (n = 120) were surveyed, with 50 responding (42% response rate). Though most respondents were food secure, approximately 15% were food insecure. Results indicated that participants ate more produce (76%), made better eating choices (74%), spent less money on food (74%), were more physically active (66%), and made new friends (74%). Food insecurity was associated with eating more produce (p < 0.05) and spending less money on food (p = 0.05) due to gardening, which warrants further exploration.