The interaction of band 3, the 95-kDa anion-exchange protein of the human erythrocyte membrane, with a variety of nonionic detergents was studied. Band 3 dimers (Stokes radius = 76 angstrom) prepared in octaethylene glycol monododecyl ether (C-12E8) could be exchanged into a variety of detergents by size-exclusion high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), with complete removal of C-12E8 from band 3 being confirmed using radiolabeled detergent. Critical micellar concentration (cmc) values, determined for all detergents in the buffer used for HPLC analysis, ranged from 0.47 muM to 223 mM. Band 3 was found to aggregate in all detergents below their cmc, and concentrations of detergents 2-200 times the cmc were required to prevent aggregation. For detergents with a low cmc, it was important to ensure that the concentration of detergent micelles minimally equalled the concentration of protein. Hydrodynamic measurements and cross-linking studies showed that band 3 remained dimeric in most detergents above their cmc. Furthermore, circular dichroism and inhibitor binding studies supported the view that band 3 can retain its native structure after detergent exchange. Detergents with short alkyl chains (C-8) denature band 3, while detergents with longer alkyl chains (C-12) maintained the native structure of band 3. The ability to exchange band 3 into a variety of detergents with the maintenance of native structure is an essential prerequisite for crystallization trials. The results obtained in this study of band 3, a model polytopic (multispanning) membrane protein, may be generally applicable to other membrane proteins.